Lucille is a pizzeria with all the toppings. The flatiron-shaped building, in the downtown Capitol Square section of Madison, Wis., first served as an early 20th-century bank. Two local restaurateurs, Patrick Sweeney and Joshua Berkson, teamed with investor Urban Land Interests to buy the 9,340-sf building—most recently used as the offices of a newspaper—and make it into an hip, environmentally sound pizza parlor.
Design firm OPN Architects and contractor Ideal Builders examined historic photos and drawings of the building to determine its original features, which had been abused by a 1970s renovation. They gutted the interior, uncovering handsome brick masonry walls, rugged steel beams, a terrazzo floor, tall arched windows—even a nearly century-old mural painted on an adjacent wall welcoming the “new” Capital City Bank.
The first floor features a zinc bar and an authentic Neapolitan pizza oven. The owners wanted the kitchen to be open to the exterior as well as the interior, but the local health code forbade such a configuration, for fear of vermin infiltration. The designers came up with a solution that isolated the mechanical system to prevent pests from getting in. Sweeney and Berkson instituted operations standards that satisfied health authorities that unwanted visitors would not be welcome.
In the lower lounge, a bank vault was turned into seating for up to 40. The contractor cut an opening in the two-foot-thick reinforced concrete wall so that diners would be able to get out if the vault door was accidentally closed. Whew!
Photo: Mike Rebholz Architectural Photography.
Project Summary
Silver Award WInner
Building Team: OPN Architects (submitting firm, architect) Strategic Structural Design (SE) JDR Engineering (MEP) Ideal Builders (GC).
Details: 9,340 sf. Total cost: $1.3 million. Construction time: January 2015 to May 2016. Delivery method: Design-build.
See all of the 2017 Reconstruction Award winners here
Related Stories
Reconstruction Awards | Nov 27, 2017
Patient friendly: The University of Chicago Medicine Center for Care and Discovery adds 203 new beds
Strict infection control and life safety measures were implemented to protect patients on other floors as work proceeded.
Reconstruction Awards | Nov 27, 2017
The birthplace of General Motors
The automotive giant salvages the place from which it sprang, 131 years ago.
Reconstruction Awards | Nov 21, 2017
Honor Guard: San Francisco’s historic Veterans Building pays homage to those who served in World War I and other foreign wars
The Veterans Building houses the War Memorial staff, the city’s Arts Commission, the Opera’s learning center and practice/performance node, the Green Room reception venue, and the 916-seat Herbst Theatre.
Reconstruction Awards | Nov 20, 2017
Eyes wide open: Students can see their new home’s building elements
The two-phase project revamped an opaque, horseshoe-shaped labyrinth of seven buildings from the ’60s and ’70s.
Reconstruction Awards | Nov 17, 2017
Gray lady no more: A facelift erases a landmark’s wrinkles, but not her heritage
The Building Team restored the granite and terra cotta façade and reclaimed more than 500 double-hung windows.
Reconstruction Awards | Nov 17, 2017
Elegance personified: New life for a neglected but still imposing retail/office space
The building was in such disrepair that much of the reconstruction budget had to go toward structural, mechanical, and electrical infrastructure improvements.
Reconstruction Awards | Nov 16, 2017
Back to the '20s: Coney Island gets a new eatery reminiscent of the past
This project included the restoration of the landmark Childs Restaurant.
Reconstruction Awards | Nov 15, 2017
Foyer fantastique: Faded images provide the key to a historic theater's lobby restoration
The restoration relied heavily on historic photos and drawings.
Reconstruction Awards | Nov 14, 2017
Hallowed ground: A Mormon temple rises from the ashes of a fire-ravaged historic tabernacle
Parts of the tabernacle’s exterior shell were the only things that survived the blaze.
Reconstruction Awards | Nov 13, 2017
Harlem Renaissance: A vacant school provides much-needed housing and a clubhouse for children
Word that PS 186 might be demolished brought out the preservationists, whose letter-writing campaign gained the support of the New York Landmarks Conservancy.
