In 2013, Chieh Huang and others launched Boxed, an online wholesale retailer that quickly grew to over $100 million in annual sales—largely through automation. Last year, for example, it roboticized its entire fulfillment center in New Jersey. As the new system was being installed, one line worker asked Huang, “Are you still going to need me when that thing goes live?” The company managed to redeploy everyone and not lose a single staffer. “Automation is great for profits,” Huang told Fortune, “but it’s a real potential trouble area for society.”
The numbers back this up. Forbes estimates that automation can improve productivity by 25-38% and save larger companies millions every year. At the same time, according a recent report from the McKinsey Global Institute, a third of the U.S. workforce and 800 million jobs worldwide could be replaced by 2030. Half of all work-related activities today are potentially automatable. At first blush, these stats suggest that automation is good for companies, but bad for jobs. Yet, the McKinsey report quotes a 1960s Federal commission: “Technology destroys jobs, but not work.” Yes, some Boxed employees lost their previous jobs, but no one was out of work. Greater productivity and efficiency can create new opportunities while eliminating others, and these changes signal seismic shifts in every industry.
This column is the first in a monthly series in BD+C that will address how automation and artificial intelligence (AI) will alter the nature of design and construction industry. Over the past couple of decades, computerized processes have significantly aided architects and builders by improving workflow, but to date those processes have not become automated on a large scale. Experiments in automated design and robotic construction remain just that—experiments. But that’s about to change.
A 2013 Oxford University study estimated that onsite construction jobs are 88% likely to be replaced by robots within a decade or two. That’s nearly nine out of every 10 bricklayers, carpenters, and anyone who picks up a hammer or shovel. “There will come a day when no human labor is present on any construction site,” robotics expert A. Scott Howe told me a decade ago.
What about architects and engineers? The Oxford study calculates the probability of eliminating engineers as only 10-13%, while the loss of architects is less than 2% likely. Yet, technology guru Kevin Kelly isn’t so sure. “Robot replacement is just a matter of time,” he wrote in Wired in 2012. “It doesn’t matter if you are a doctor, lawyer, architect, reporter, or even programmer.”
We asked BD+C readers to weigh in, and our recent survey presents a fascinating snapshot of the industry’s excitement and anxiety about technology. The vast majority of respondents have a positive view, with 83% agreeing automation and AI can help create better buildings. Designers and builders vary only slightly, with 81% of designers and 89% of builders agreeing. When asked whether automation threatens job security, only 24% say “yes.” A quarter of contractors see any risk, even though the evidence suggests otherwise.
Over three-quarters (78%) of everyone polled say AI will never match human intelligence, but the variation between designers and contractors is nearly 20 points—81% of designers and 63% of contractors. Meanwhile, AI experts such as Google’s Ray Kurzweil insist that computers will meet or exceed human intelligence by the middle of this century.
The question about which readers seem most ambivalent is whether automation’s ability to create better structures justifies job loss in the industry. A slight majority (54%) answered affirmatively: 52% of designers and 58% of contractors. So designers are almost perfectly divided on this question: they are convinced AI can improve architecture, but they aren’t threatened by this fact, and they are torn about whether the improvements justify fewer jobs.
In the coming months, we will unpack all of this. How will automation advance the built environment, and how will it affect traditional practices and professions? And what are the aims of our industry: to create more opportunity for ourselves or to enhance communities?
Let us know your questions and views. We’re all ears. Contact me at https://lancehosey.com/contact/.
Lance Hosey, FAIA, LEED Fellow, is a Design Director with Gensler. His book, The Shape of Green: Aesthetics, Ecology, and Design, has been an Amazon #1 bestseller in the Sustainability & Green Design category.
Related Stories
AEC Tech | Apr 17, 2019
4 fundamental relationships between buildings and machines
If and when AI drives the entire process of design, construction, and operation, buildings could become exponentially smarter with resources, money, time, and performance.
AEC Tech | Apr 12, 2019
NBBJ creates Design Performance Group whose goal is to connect building design with occupant wellbeing
The firm also wants to advance energy efficiency in its projects.
AEC Tech | Apr 10, 2019
Speaker Update! Accelerate AEC Innovation Conference, May 13-14, NYC
BD+C's third-annual Accelerate AEC Innovation Conference (May 13-14, NYC) will explore AI in architecture, offsite construction, smart buildings, AEC business innovations, big data in construction, and much more.
AEC Tech | Mar 26, 2019
Embracing collaboration tools from outside the AEC industry
Let's take a look at the available technologies from outside AEC that are seeing greater adoption within the industry.
AEC Tech | Mar 24, 2019
5 ways designers and builders can use business intelligence with data they already have
Tricky construction budgets, large project teams, and unique designs needing extensive coordination are all problems increasingly being handled with new software tools and data.
AEC Tech | Feb 8, 2019
BI(m): BIM data without models
A new breed of data tools creates a valuable opportunity for the next wave of BIM and facilities management, one where “pure data” is at the center, writes John Tobin of SMRT Architects.
3D Printing | Dec 7, 2018
Additive manufacturing heads to the jobsite
Prototype mobile 3D printing shop aims to identify additive manufacturing applications for construction jobsites.
AEC Tech | Sep 27, 2018
BD+C editors want your input on AEC technology
Please help us improve our editorial coverage by taking this brief survey.
Sponsored | AEC Tech | Sep 14, 2018
Sponsored webinar: Benefits of traceable construction
In this free 60-minute webinar, Keith Alcorn of FARO Technologies will talk about the concept of traceable construction and how 3D reality capture solutions provide portable, efficient, secure, and forward-looking solutions for data collection, pre-processing, and evaluation in the design, build and operating phase. September 18, 2:00 EST.
AEC Tech | Jul 24, 2018
Weidt Group’s Net Energy Optimizer now available as software as a service
The proprietary energy analysis tool is open for use by the public.