HorizonTV Featuring BD+C: Watch Episodes On Demand At HorizonTV

Healthcare Design That Strips the Atom

Proton therapy is changing the way physicians treat cancer—and changing the design criteria for treatment centers that offer the revolutionary therapy.

February 01, 2007 |

In proton therapy, the medical team directs a beam of sub-atomic protons at the patient's tumor site. The protons are able to accurately target and kill tumors—both near the surface and seated deep within the human body—while minimizing damage to surrounding tissues and organs. This is a particular problem for tumors around optical nerves, the spinal cord, the head and neck, the prostate, and the central nervous system, areas where conventional radiation would damage the surrounding tissue.

Proton therapy utilizes a more controlled dose of radiation than other radiation treatments, thereby reducing severe side effects to healthy tissue. But building cancer treatment centers that can handle the process that unlocks the potential of protons comes with its own side effects for Building Teams.

“You essentially have to shield the area from escaping neutrons, the reactionary particles in the neutron bomb,” says Ed Tsoi, FAIA, principal of design firm Tsoi/Kobus & Associates, Cambridge, Mass., which has designed four proton therapy cancer centers: the University of Texas M. D. Anderson Cancer Center, Houston; the University of Pennsylvania Health System Roberts Proton Therapy Center, Philadelphia; the Massachusetts General Hospital Cancer Center, Boston; and the University of Florida's Shands Jacksonville Medical Center.

Keeping the neutrons from escaping

The initial problem of creating atomic reactions is keeping dangerous radiation, such as neutrons, which are created and deflected when a proton stream collides with a tumor or wall, from escaping the treatment space. This often requires designing walls that are 6-10 feet thick for treatment rooms, and at least 10-foot-thick ceilings.

“The equipment costs more than the building itself,” says Tsoi. “So it's necessary to design the building in the most cost-effective way possible.” One way is to use the earth itself as the radiation barrier and build the treatment rooms below ground.

In urban facilities such as the Roberts Proton Therapy Center, where below-grade construction would be hampered by the building above, it was necessary to design thick concrete planks that interlock like Lincoln Logs, to allow part of the ceiling to be removed if major pieces of equipment need to be maintained or replaced.

For the M. D. Anderson Cancer Center, which opened last summer, the program includes four proton therapy rooms, an imaging center, and experimental areas for research. The target is to treat 3,000 patients a year, among them the 40% of U.S. males who will have prostate cancer at some time in their lives, according to the American Cancer Society.

The institutions and business partners who are planning tomorrow's proton therapy centers have become more concerned about how many patients can be treated per day and per year. “The cost to construction these facilities is obviously very high so we are focused on how to get higher utilization of equipment,” Tsoi said. If set-up for each patient is reduced and the staff is available to treat patients beyond a normal 8-hour day, there is an improved return on investment. Once the equipment is in place, the challenge is to find the means to offer this treatment to as wide a variety of patients as possible.”

Typical treatments take 30-45 minutes and are painless. While results can vary significantly based on the types of patients seen, the kinds of tumors treated, and the stage of the disease, proton therapy has yielded very high success rates for well-defined tumors—in the upper 90% range.

“The push from the physicians, physicists, and businesspeople that invest in these facilities is to find a way to apply this protocol to new sites such as lung and breast cancer,” says Tsoi. “We're seeing research into new cancer sites at places like MGH, M. D. Anderson, University of Floriad and Loma Linda as well as overseas in Europe and Asia.”

How proton therapy works

As you remember from high school physics, protons and neutrons form the nuclei of atoms; electrons orbit the nuclei. In radiation therapy, physicists separate positively charged protons from hydrogen atoms by stripping off negatively charged electrons with powerful magnets. They then bend the protons into a “stream” and accelerate it in a circular path (using a cyclotron or synchrotron) at nearly the speed of light. The speed of the resulting beam, and therefore its energy, is measured in electron volts: the higher the electron voltage, the heavier the impact of the beam upon a tumor in a patient's body.

Although both proton therapy and conventional radiation therapy work by aiming the energized particles at the target tumor, ultimately destroying the DNA of cancer cells, they release energy in different ways. Radiation x-rays release their energy quickly after penetrating the skin, disrupting the molecules of healthy tissues and cancerous cells alike, whereas protons can be manipulated to release their energy only when they reach the target. In addition, x-rays continue through the body past the tumor, while protons go no farther than the target itself; thus, more energy reaches the cancerous cells, reducing the side effects of the therapy.
Healthcare projects under construction

Dublin Methodist Hospital

Dublin, Ohio

5 stories; 500,000 sf

$150 million

OhioHealth Systems (O); Karlsberger Companies (A); Elford Inc. (JVCM); Gilbane Building Co. (JVCM)

Edward Hospital Heart Building

Naperville, Ill.

3 stories

$49.7 million

Edward Hospital and Health Services (O); Matthei & Colin (A); Pepper Construction (GC)

Exeter Hospital

Exeter, N.H.

200,000 sf

$50 million

Exeter Hospital (O); Robert Corson (A); JSA Inc. (AA); Hutter Construction (GC)

Florida Hospital Ormond, replacement facility

Ormond, Fla.

600,000 sf

$70 million

Adventist Health Systems (O); Florida Hospital Ormond Memorial (AO); Hunton Brady Architects (A); Robins & Morton (GC)

Geary Community Hospital

Junction City, Kan.

2 stories; 90,000 sf

$34 million

Geary Community Hospital (O); Hoefer Wysocki Architects (A); Capital Performance Management (CM)

Greater Lafayette Health Services

Lafayette, Ind.

4 stories; 405,000 sf

$55 million

Greater Lafayette Health Services (O); BSA- LifeStructures (A); Tonn & Blank (GC)

Holy Family Hospital, medical offices

Spokane, Wash.

4 stories; 107,600 sf

$35.8 million

Holy Family Hospital (O); Nex Core Group (D); Northwest Architectural Co. (A); Bouten Construction (GC)

Ingham Regional Medical Center

Lansing, Mich.

5 stories; 157,954 sf

$25 million

Ingham Regional Medical Center (O); HBE Corp. (A, GC)

John Muir Hospital

Walnut Creek, Calif.

5 stories; 443,000 sf

757 parking spaces

$167 million

John Muir Medical Center (O); Ratcliff Architects (A); Kier & Wright Civil Engineers (CE); Arup Engineering (SE); Mazzetti & Associates (M/E); Turner Construction Co. (GC)

Lakeland Regional Health Systems, hospital

Saint Joseph, Mich.

4 stories; 142,000 sf

607 parking spaces

$66 million

Lakeland Regional Health Systems (O); BSA LifeStructures (A, CE, M/E, SE); Barton Malow (JVGC); Shelton Construction (JVGC)

Lancaster General Rehabilitation Hospital

East Hempfield Township, Pa.

52,000 sf

$50 million

Lancaster General Hospital (O); Cogdell Spenser Group (D); Ramseur Peterson Architects (A); Benchmark Construction Co. (GC)

Marshfield Clinic

Rice Lake, Wis.

2 stories; 138,200 sf

$43 million

Marshfield Clinic (O); Marshall Erdman & Associates (CE, M/E, SE, DB)

Memorial Hermann Heart and Vascular Institute Southwest


5 stories; 173,000 sf

$65 million

Memorial Hermann Healthcare Systems (O); Mac Haik Realty Corp. (AO); Trammell Crow Co. (D); WHR Architects (A); Vaughn Construction (GC)

Mercy Hospital, replacement hospital, phase 1 and 2

Portland, Maine

265,000 sf

$117 million

Catholic Health East (O); Mercy Hospital Facilities (AO); Francis Cauffman Foley Hoffman Architect (A); Gilbane Building Co. (CM); KLMK Group (AO, phase 2)

Mercy Medical Center

Merced, Calif.

7 stories; 258,714 sf

948 parking spaces

$53.6 million

Mercy Medical Cancer Center (O); McCarthy (GC); Harris & Associates (CM)

Methodist Outpatient Center, phase 1


10 stories, 300,000 sf

$70 million

Methodist Hospital (O); WHR Architects Inc. (A); Hensel Phelps (GC); Broaddus & Associates (CM)

Provena Saint Joseph Hospital, phase 2

Elgin, Ill.

4 stories; 60,000 sf

$97 million

Provena Saint Joseph Hospital (O); Wilmot Sanz (A); Landmark Engineering (CE); Cagley & Associates (SE); Robert G Burkhardt & Associates (M/E); Turner Construction Co. (GC)

Provena Saint Joseph Medical Center, bed tower

Joliet, Ill.

8 stories; 1,000,000 sf

$138 million

Provena St. Joseph Medical Center (O); PFB Architects (A); Ruettiger Tonelli & Associates (CE); HDR Architecture Inc. (SE); KJWW Engineering Consultants (M/E); Pepper Construction (GC)

Riley Hospital, phase 5

Indianapolis, Ind.

10 stories

$200 million

Riley Hospital for Children (O); Structural Design Inc. (A); Pepper Construction (GC)

Saint Luke's West Campus Outpatient Center

Chesterfield, Mo.

5 stories; 150,000 sf

$50 million

St Luke's Hospital (O); ACI/Boland (A); McCarthy (GC)

Saint Peter's Hospital, phase 4

Albany, N.Y.

$30 million

Saint Peter's Hospital (O); Central Consulting (OR); Envision Architects (A); FreemanWhite (AA)

Scott and White Hospital

Round Rock, Texas

4 stories; 196,000 sf

$81 million

Scott & White Hospital (O); Hammes Co. (AO); PageSoutherlandPage (A); Vaughn Construction (GC)

Scottsdale Healthcare Thompson Peak, hospital

Scottsdale, Ariz.

$77 million

Scottsdale Healthcare Realty (O); Earl Swensson Associates (A); Kitchell Contractors (GC)

Source: Reed Construction Data. For more construction related economic information please visit www.BuildingTeamForecast.com. For related questions email RCD at ReedForecast@ReedBusiness.com

A Architect

AA Associate architect

AO Associate owner

C Consultant

CE Civil engineer

CM Construction manager

D Developer

DB Design-builder

DR Developer's representative

GC General contractor

ID Interior designer

JVCM Joint venture construction manager

JVGC Joint venture general contractor

M/E/P Mechanical/electrical/plumbing engineer

O Owner

OR Owner's representative

SE Structural engineer
Overlay Init

Your card will be charged: 0