HorizonTV Featuring BD+C: Watch Episodes On Demand At HorizonTV

In search of better data to optimize tall buildings

In spite of the ability to build tall and taller buildings—usually fully glazed, often in extreme climates with increasingly smart technologies—it could be argued that we are not similarly “rising to the occasion” in terms of optimization, writes Gensler's Russell Gilchrist.

January 04, 2017 |
Gensler Dialogue Blog

Extraordinary technological advances have taken tall buildings to new heights, quite literally. Whereas in 1973 Chicago’s Willis Tower was the tallest of them all at 442 meters (1,451 feet), Jeddah Tower in Saudi Arabia will assume that distinction in 2020 or thereabouts, leapfrogging all other super- and megatall buildings with a height of 1,000 meters. Advances in structural systems, high-strength concrete and steel, vertical transportation, and glass and steel façades largely made it possible.

In spite of this ability to build tall and taller buildings—usually fully glazed, often in extreme climates with increasingly smart technologies—it could be argued that we are not similarly “rising to the occasion” in terms of optimization. We’re not optimizing the user experience, occupant comfort, and energy reductions that taller structures inherently offer because we don’t have the best data to do that. Perhaps it’s time to add another technological advance—drones—into the design process for the purpose of creating not just the tallest but the most responsible tall buildings.

A matter of size and scale

It’s important to understand that optimization is always critical, but perhaps more so when talking about very tall buildings simply because of their scale and all the ripple effects. For instance, reducing a megatall’s weight by even two percent through optimizing its structure can result in a significant reduction in steel and concrete. And this, in turn, has an impact on foundation loads and (potentially) wind forces.

Although from a structural perspective, we do know a lot about the effects of wind on a tall building and on adjacent buildings and public spaces (via wind tunnel testing), we continue to question what impact air temperature and air quality have on tall buildings. The answer is probably quite a lot and, yet, we can’t guarantee those effects, let alone quantify them. And as for those wind forces we understand so well, we’re probably falling short on our full understanding of them, simply because we rely on meteorological data collected at the closest airport and not actual wind speed data specific to the site. Wind conditions at an airport, generally a low-rise area, are likely to be different from the urbanized environment of a tall building project.

The beauty of site-specific data

What passive virtues or challenges might exist if these numbers were more clearly recorded on-site and understood within the context of, perhaps, using that high-velocity air to optimize building systems? Same with temperature gradients. Explorers and mountaineers are familiar with changes in atmospheric conditions when they ascend to greater altitudes. Shouldn’t we understand the range of temperatures that a megatall building is exposed to as it ascends and how air quality improves? Consider how we might optimize heating and cooling systems throughout the height of a building if the changing external conditions were more explicitly known.


Shanghai Tower. Image © Gensler.


So what does this mean for the design of tall buildings? Let’s use as an example a 600-meter (about 2,000-foot) mixed-use tower in Philadelphia where summers are fairly hot and humid, and the winters are chilly. In summer, when the temperature at grade could be 93 degrees, it’s likely to be 10 degrees cooler 600 meters up. In winter, temperature at the grade level could be 14 F, but at 600 meters up, it’s around -6 F, or 20 degrees cooler.

Let’s say the occupants of this imaginary 600-meter tower (with 150 floors and total square footage comparable to that of Willis Tower) expect an internal air temperature of 72 degrees, year round. We know that buildings are in cooling mode during the summer and heating mode during winter. What if we used our understanding of varying external temperatures to optimize the HVAC system and occupant comfort? In the summer, the 83-degree air at the top of the building would be drawn in and cooled by 11 degrees to achieve the desired 72 degrees. That would represent a significant savings over intake at ground level where the outside air is 93 degrees. In the winter, the reverse approach seems sensible. Outside air would be supplied from the lower levels of the building at 14 F rather than from the top where the temperature is below 0 F. Given the scale of the building, this optimization and calibration of internal HVAC equipment could significantly reduce energy use and carbon emissions.

Imagine the glass and steel façade of that same megatall as having an external surface area measuring as much as 12.6 hectares (roughly 31 acres). Two-thirds of this area will be exposed to direct solar glare, and 100 percent will be susceptible to moisture ingress and energy loss through the building envelope. Air leakage and infiltration rates are based on a standard factor (0.06 CFM/ft2) irrespective of building height, even though it is now understood that air leakage will increase at higher altitudes. We have already noted that air temperature reduces at altitude, while wind speed and pressure increase. All of these varying conditions would affect the performance of a 150-story building, but we have limited data to quantify that.

In addition, tall buildings have another phenomenon to consider called the “stack effect “ in which hot or cold air rises or descends through the volume of the building via elevator shafts, creating varying conditions on each floor and fluctuating throughout the calendar year.

Drone-assisted architecture

Currently, the world has 108 completed supertall and three megatall buildings. Potentially all of them have an undersized heating system and an oversized cooling system, the consequence of using generic weather data that didn’t account for varying wind speeds, air temperatures, and air quality at different heights. With today’s drone technology, these conditions could be recorded at various height datums to help architects and engineers better predict actual climate variables. That would enable us to do something truly effective: optimize building systems and facades to design and deliver the most efficient, responsible and comfortable skyscrapers we possibly can.

Gensler Dialogue Blog | Gensler

Published by Gensler, a global design firm with 5,000 practitioners networked across five continents, Gensler Dialogue Blog features insights and opinions of architects and designers on how design innovation makes cities more livable, work smarter, and leisure more engaging. Our contributors write about projects of every scale, from refreshing a retailer’s brand to planning a new urban district, all the while explaining how great design can optimize business performance and human potential. For more blog posts, visit: https://www.gensler.com/research-insight/blog.

Related Blogs

July 15, 2019 | Healthcare Facilities | GenslerAmy Carter, Bethany Callihan, and James Crispino

Below are five strategies to improve access and patient experience.

How the Internet of Things will transform airport environments

Auckland Airport — Auckland, New Zealand. Photo courtesy Gensler

May 20, 2019 | Airports | GenslerScott Gorenc, AIA, LEED AP, Senior Designer, Gensler

Connected devices and their wealth of data have led to significant improvements in operational efficiency a...

April 30, 2019 | GenslerDiane Hoskins

Our data reveal what is truly going on in the current workplace, with insights on how workplace design can...

It’s time for office amenities to get to work

At Campari Group’s new North American headquarters in New York, four distinct bar-like experiences offer more than just a place for employees and guests to blow off steam. Photo courtesy Gensler

April 08, 2019 | Office Building Design | GenslerAmanda Carroll, IIDA, CID, LEED AP, Workplace Leader, Principal, Gensler

Amenities with the greatest impact on effectiveness and experience are those that directly support the work...

How the built environment can help the climate crisis

Courtesy Pixabay

November 05, 2018 | Sustainability | GenslerAnthony Brower

Our buildings and cities will have to experiment with new climate responsive forms, and in many cases, the...

Leland Federal Building

The G.T. "Mickey" Leland Federal Building in Houston. Image © Joe Aker.

October 03, 2018 | Sustainability | GenslerChris Mundell And Maria Perez

Many companies are influenced by the misconception that only some projects can qualify as sustainable.

Comcast Studio Xfinity

For Comcast Studio Xfinity's new flagship in Washington, D.C., Gensler created an engaging experiential brand program that informed the store's interior design and created a warm, social, and inviting environment. Image © Chris Leonard.

September 17, 2018 | Retail Centers | GenslerRyan Cavanaugh

One way to solve for the future is to disrupt the expected.

August 27, 2018 | Office Building Design | GenslerJanet Pogue McLaurin

The degree of open or enclosed doesn't matter in high-performing work environments. If the space is designe...

The CSU Northridge Sustainability + Recycling Center

The CSU Northridge Sustainability + Recycling Center includes a rooftop photovoltaic system, which offsets the energy required to support the building's administrative functions. Glazed, north-facing overhead windows bring in natural light that enhances the work environment for staff and creates a daylight autonomous environment. The design eliminates the need for artificial light in the building during daylight hours. Ryan Gobuty, Image © Gensler.

August 06, 2018 | Energy | GenslerAnthony Brower

The architecture, engineering, and construction industry will have to make major adjustments in the years a...

A day in the life of an ‘agile worker’

A mix of sit-stand stations and collaboration areas support agile working. Image © Gensler/John Ryan.

July 18, 2018 | Office Building Design | GenslerJane Stull

When our Gensler La Crosse office relocated last year, we leveraged the opportunity to support an agile wor...

Overlay Init

Your card will be charged: 0