flexiblefullpage -
billboard - default
interstitial1 - interstitial
Currently Reading

The generalist architect vs. the specialist architect

Architects

The generalist architect vs. the specialist architect


By Gary Harris, AIA | SRG Partnership | February 9, 2015
The generalist architect vs. the specialist architect

Image courtesy SRG Partnership

Upon graduating from architecture school so many years ago, I embarked on a career wide-eyed and full of vigor to design wonderful buildings and public spaces to be enjoyed by mankind. In school you aren’t necessarily trained to specialize in any one building type or facet of practicing architecture. But a funny thing happens as an architect’s career develops. Some people end up working in firms that specialize in certain building types, like hospitals or schools. Pretty soon they become very knowledgeable about that building sector and they become specialists. However, the need for designing for a certain building sector can wane and those specialists have a hard time adapting to the discovery process needed for designing other types of buildings.

Some of us end up taking a different course. I started out working for an A&E firm where, besides drafting plans and details for the senior architects, I drew structural details, HVAC plans and riser diagrams, electrical power and lighting plans. This work didn't exactly satisfy the creative nature in my architectural soul, but it taught me valuable lessons of collaborating with different disciplines and learning a whole lot about how buildings are put together. I soon moved on to another firm that specialized in K-12 schools. I did that for five years before moving to a firm that did mostly commercial office buildings. And then eventually it was back to public sector architecture, which is what revs my engines.

I have been a project architect while working for a few different firms on underground transit stations to high-rise buildings to airport terminals, from libraries to museums to higher education academic buildings. Add in churches, apartment buildings, and single-family residences, and in a flash of three to four decades I have become the consummate generalist. I have been able to participate in a broad spectrum of building types, and in all facets of practice, from schematic design to construction administration. I am good at doing many things, but I am not an expert in any one thing. I am more facile than the specialist and can adapt very easily. The specialist can be more streamlined and expert in their chosen specialty, but they are limited if they want to expand their business.

The corporate world today quite often insists on hiring specialists, but the generalists have an intrinsic quality to adapt to new horizons or even cultural shifts in the market. Carter Phillips, author of "Evolutionaries: Unlocking the Spiritual and Cultural Potential of Science’s Greatest Idea," states that generalists will thrive in a culture where it’s becoming increasingly valuable to know “a little bit about a lot.” It takes a generalist to “weave the ideas of a specialist into a broader fabric of understanding.”

I think the most successful firms are generalist in their nature but are smart enough to have a right mix of both on their staff. If you can bring that specialist to the table to convince a particular client that you have the best team, your chances for success increase. Eventually, a firm that develops a resume of a variety of building types and services will be the most successful in the market.

So the debate will no doubt continue. I will leave you with these “fighting words” from each camp:

The trouble with generalists is that they know less and less about more and more, until eventually know nothing about everything.

The trouble with specialists is that they know more and more about less and less, until eventually know everything about nothing.

About the Author: During his 40 years of architectural practice, Gary Harris, AIA, has worked as project manager and project architect for major academic, civic, and institutional facilities. More on Harris.

More from Author

SRG Partnership | Aug 10, 2022

Increasing the skilled workforce through career technical education

There is a shortage of skilled workers in the United States, a gap that has only gotten wider with the advent of COVID.

SRG Partnership | Aug 8, 2022

Mass timber and net zero design for higher education and lab buildings

When sourced from sustainably managed forests, the use of wood as a replacement for concrete and steel on larger scale construction projects has myriad economic and environmental benefits that have been thoroughly outlined in everything from academic journals to the pages of Newsweek.

SRG Partnership | Jun 9, 2016

Designing for interdisciplinary communication in university buildings

Bringing people together remains the main objective when designing academic projects. SRG Design Principal Kent Duffy encourages interaction and discovery with a variety of approaches. 

SRG Partnership | May 21, 2015

How CLT wood construction affects project cost

SRG Partnership's Emily Dawson shares insights on the installation, availablilty, and cost of cross-laminated timber (CLT) construction, based on the firm's recent project at the Oregon Zoo.

SRG Partnership | Apr 9, 2015

How one team solved a tricky daylighting problem with BIM/VDC tools, iterative design

SRG Partnership's Scott Mooney describes how Grasshopper, Diva, Rhino, and 3D printing were utilized to optimize a daylighting scheme at Oregon State University's new academic building.

SRG Partnership | Mar 23, 2015

Drones for AEC: How every stage of a building project can benefit from drone technology

From photo-mapping to aerial progress videos, SRG Partnership's Dmitriy Molla studies real-world applications for unmanned aerial vehicles.

SRG Partnership | Jan 5, 2015

Beyond training: How locker rooms are becoming more like living rooms

Despite having common elements—lockers for personal gear and high-quality sound systems—the real challenge when designing locker rooms is creating a space that reflects the attitude of the team, writes SRG Partnership's Aaron Pleskac.

SRG Partnership | Dec 18, 2014

In response to ultra-open and uber-collaborative office environments

Susan Cain’s bestselling 2012 book, "Quiet: The Power of Introverts in a World That Can’t Stop Talking" has made an impact on how we understand our current workforce, recognizing that at least one-third of the people we work with are introverts, writes SRG Partnership's Susan Gust.

boombox1 - default
boombox2 -
native1 -

More In Category




halfpage1 -

Most Popular Content

  1. 2021 Giants 400 Report
  2. Top 150 Architecture Firms for 2019
  3. 13 projects that represent the future of affordable housing
  4. Sagrada Familia completion date pushed back due to coronavirus
  5. Top 160 Architecture Firms 2021

 



Magazine Subscription
Subscribe

Get our Newsletters

Each day, our editors assemble the latest breaking industry news, hottest trends, and most relevant research, delivered to your inbox.

Subscribe

Follow BD+C: