Assembly (and rigorous planning) required: Managing the pros and cons of modular construction

While offering efficiency and flexibility, modular construction requires extensive planning and collaboration to avoid potential challenges.

September 24, 2018 |
Stantec Blog

As a buildings engineer, I’ve had the fulfilling opportunity to travel for work, experiencing new cities, learning about emerging building techniques, and seeing firsthand how new projects play an important role in complementing the fabric of a community. But it’s not often that I can say my projects are also certified globetrotters.

New York City’s largest modular hotel, the CitizenM Hotel on Manhattan’s Lower East Side, is just that: The project concept originated in Amsterdam, was built in Poland, shipped to Brooklyn in 210 pieces, and then assembled in its permanent home in the Bowery neighborhood. Clocking in at 20 stories tall with 300 guestrooms, the CitizenM is a prime example of how modular can be leveraged on a large scale.

 

Dense urban environments can pose unique challenges for the delivery and assembly of modules used in modular construction projects.

 

Modular construction—a building process where building components are fabricated off-site in a controlled manufacturing setting, and then constructed on-site—is rising as a construction strategy here in the US after years of popularity in Europe. Valued for offering greater efficiency and quality control, modular construction is gaining ground across all property types, from multi-family and hospitality, to education and lab space.

The CitizenM Hotel and projects like it are paving a new frontier in the US for more efficient and flexible construction. In fact, industry observers expect the number of new commercial projects delivered via modular construction  in North America to nearly double over the next five years.

But with such great advantages comes potential challenges that all project teams should prepare for to ensure success.

 

Modular benefits

We often field questions from clients across the country considering whether modular construction is the right fit. The technique certainly allows for several advantages as outlined below:

— Greater quality control: Because much of the workmanship occurs in a controlled factory setting, there is greater regulation over the fabrication of each module. This helps ensure consistent quality and helps minimize errors in the field.

— Increased efficiency of architectural layouts: Developers, architects, and engineers are forced to maximize the efficiency of the physical floor space. As a result, they must be more creative and collaborative in the design approach.

— Maximized productivity: Since fabrication occurs off-site, other work can happen on-site concurrently without disruption. Also, weather disruptions become less of a factor when a majority of a project is manufactured indoors.

— Improved construction schedule: On average, modular projects can be completed faster than traditional construction.
 

The number of new commercial projects in North America delivered through modular construction is expected to nearly double over the next five years.

 

Preparing for possible challenges

While there’s much to be said about the benefits of modular building, there can be downfalls if the team isn’t prepared to manage the increased need for collaboration and logistical planning. Our team has learned a great deal through partnering on modular projects to anticipate inherent challenges such as:

— Recognizing learning curves: It’s true that modular is gaining steam across the country, but it’s important to recognize that all project partners may not be highly experienced in this building model. Similarly, local authorities may also be catching up on modular and working to perfect their inspections and approval processes. Because of this, proactive and consistent communication with all stakeholders is essential. The greater the collaboration, the greater opportunity to anticipate challenges and address solutions.

— Coordination: This lesson applies to all projects, since no two buildings are the same. But, it’s worth noting that modular adds another highly unique layer to design and engineering considerations. In the case of CitizenM, we had to look at the design of the building systems in a new way. Each module, or pod, required additional design coordination, which consisted of design drawings produced at a shop drawing or 3D level to minimize horizontal and vertical conflicts, and to ensure that all components can be installed, accessed, and maintained. Due to the size of the floorplates, and the load calculations of the guestrooms, we designed 15 MEP shafts within the building interior that would be linked with the pods as they were stacked like Legos.

— Height considerations: Owners and architects need to plan for additional floor-to-floor heights and additional space between pods. Each pod has an independent wall, floor, and ceiling structure/cavity. This is unlike conventional construction where two adjacent rooms share the same wall, and two stacked rooms share the same ceiling/floor.

— Transporting modules: While having pre-fabricated modules on-site helps to speed construction, the logistics behind delivering these pieces to their final home requires a highly synchronized plan. Especially in a city like New York, where vast bridges and narrow, bustling roadways come into play, transportation strategy is essential to avoiding any hurdles. Coordination with local authorities is vital in ensuring a seamless delivery.

— Accommodating assembly: Special considerations also need to be made for site logistics of the crane to hoist and set modules. This is especially pertinent in dense urban environments where space for any type of construction activity is limited, let alone raising and setting modules.

With the growing need for innovative building tactics, modular construction presents a very welcome solution for many property developers seeking greater control, efficiency, and productivity. This is especially the case with smaller hotel guestrooms and residences, when design can utilize typical floor plans where the same stacked architectural layouts can take full advantage of vertical infrastructure.

Through proper planning and the ability to be nimble, project teams will find that modular creates great opportunity for creativity and successful delivery.

Stantec Blog | Stantec
Stantec

Published by global design firm Stantec, this eclectic blog features viewpoints, insights, and explanations from Stantec architects, engineers, and designers, on a range of issues impacting the fabric of our communities. Our contributors share their thoughts about design trends, emerging technologies, vexing challenges, and inspired solutions. For more blog posts, visit: www.stantec.com.

Related Blogs

August 15, 2018 | Green | StantecNels Nelson

The WELL Community Standard equips planners to build health promotion into the very fabric of neighborhoods...

An apartment-style student housing project uses patterning and window placement to generate interest on an otherwise flat façade

July 13, 2018 | Multifamily Housing | StantecBryan Morrison

While student and multi-family housing share a common building form, it’s the student resident that drives...

June 18, 2018 | Urban Planning | StantecJoe Geller

Five years ago, experts were predicting continued urban rebound and suburban decline. What really happened?...

April 18, 2018 | Sustainability | StantecHeather Greene

The future office strives to be better, focus more on the people who inhabit it, and contribute to the succ...

April 09, 2018 | Sustainability | StantecTravis Sage

Imagine a future where buildings and infrastructure are 100% utilized and 100% responsive.

March 02, 2018 | Office Building Design | StantecJenya Guillemin

These days, if your office space isn’t a true reflection of your brand, you’ve missed a big opportunity to...

Our team helped implement public improvements along 1,500 feet of Wisconsin shoreline. This project benefited from community outreach.

February 26, 2018 | Urban Planning | StantecLindsey Christopherson

A new community engagement program works with young adults to help the future of the neighborhood and get o...

November 15, 2017 | Resiliency | StantecBlake Jackson

The developer sees resilient developments achieving top-of-market pricing, faster leasing, higher renewal,...

October 25, 2017 | Healthcare Facilities | StantecDouglas King, Senior Associate, Stantec

Children often accompany parents or grandparents in medical settings; what can we do to address their uniqu...

September 25, 2017 | Architects | StantecChris Groesbeck, AIA, NCARB, LEED AP

The four-part mission of a garden of scientific research helped drive the design for the Beijing New Materi...

Overlay Init