On zero-energy cities: The idea of a zero-energy city is a subject I’ve been interested in most of my career, working in indigenous areas like Guatemala and the Middle East, looking for clues about the design of buildings in their cultural and historical fabric. For the last four years, we’ve been looking at how to relate buildings to the natural forces that are available to us—geothermal, wind, solar, building orientation, and so on.
Sears Tower as guidepost: In 2005, while Gordon Gill and I were still at SOM, we started to look at the need to not only reduce buildings’ reliance on energy, but also to absorb the energy and use the latent environment to its greatest advantage. The Sears Tower [now Willis Tower] has 10,000 panes of single-glaze glass, and each creates as much carbon as one SUV. So we looked into completely replacing the exterior wall, redoing the insulation panels, updating the mechanical systems, reducing the amount of artificial light in the inner space, using dimmer systems, greening the nine roofs, using solar provide hot water, and so on. The potential savings would be 68 million kWh a year, which translates to five million fewer miles of driving, or electricity for 2,500 homes. We concluded that we could save 80% of the base energy of the building and 50% of the tenant energy use for the building.
Decarbonizing Chicago: The Sears Tower got us thinking about the 2030 Challenge, the BOMA 7-Point Challenge, and the Chicago Climate Action Plan: What would happen if we analyzed Chicago’s Loop to meet those goals? Over the last year, our firm has conducted an extensive study, a Chicago Central Area Decarbonization Plan, to see what it would take to get a carbon-free environment by 2030. We looked at a 460-acre section of the Loop that represents 9% of the city’s emissions, 3.9 million tons of CO2e a year, to see how to get an 80% reduction by 2020 and eliminate 3.2 million tons of CO2e a year.
By taking every building in the study area, all 550, and applying what we did in the Sears Tower, you get about one-third of the way toward the 2030 Challenge. Then, if you change the “urban matrix” of the buildings in the Loop from essentially 100% office use to 50% office and 50% residential, that gets you two-thirds of the way there. And through means like smart infrastructure, increased pedestrian traffic, district cooling, reducing energy in water and waste, and community education—when you do all that, you still have about 20% of the way to go, and that 20% has to come from renewable power sources to achieve a total reduction of carbon.
New technology, new philosophy: The old technology, old philosophy is having a central power plant and transmitting the power from the central plant to each building in the city. The problem is that you’re only 40-50% efficient at the source, and you’re losing 30% more in transmission, so you’re throwing away 70-80% of the power. Using new technology with wind and solar farms still relies on transmitting energy to the city. The new technology, new philosophy is to make as much power on the site as possible. Then you can shave the peak period for all users and reduce the total number of power plants. And you don’t need the grid: every building becomes a power source.
QUESTIONS FROM THE IIT AUDIENCE
Does your plan use projections of future improvements in technology?
ADS: The Chicago decarbonization plan uses existing technology; we don’t rely on technology that doesn’t exist. As people hear about what we’re doing, new technology will become part of our daily lives. We don’t know if some of those things will work, so you can’t rely on unknown technology in the future.
What about the embodied energy of materials?
ADS: The best way you can save energy is to take something old and renew it. You have to tackle it building by building, district by district. The study showed that for $65 a square foot you could bring these buildings up to state of the art, vs. $250 a square foot to replace them.
How will you store energy for when it’s actually needed?
ADS: You have to have storage facilities to store that power, whether that’s a battery or limestone caves. This is a key area of investigation, and it’s going to take a clever solution to do this on an economical basis.
How likely is it that your plan could be implemented?
ADS: That’s a big question mark. In New York City, building owners have to do some of the things we’re talking about. This is a seed. You throw it out there.
Would the residential units be too expensive for low-income groups?
ADS: In the Loop, retrofitting the pre-1950s buildings could give you opportunity to do that, where units would be cost accessible. In the ’80s, we took a lot of abandoned manufacturing buildings and converted them into residential lofts that were quite affordable.
How do you counteract the public’s reaction to high density?
ADS: People don’t want their views blocked, and that’s where a master plan comes in, and zoning densities. Wacker’s “Manual of the Plan of Chicago” was used for 15 years after the Burnham Plan of 1909, to teach every public school student what the plan meant. We’re proposing a similar manual that creates strategies for a carbon-free environment.
Related Stories
| Aug 11, 2010
NAVFAC releases guidelines for sustainable reconstruction of Navy facilities
The guidelines provide specific guidance for installation commanders, assessment teams, estimators, programmers and building designers for identifying the sustainable opportunities, synergies, strategies, features and benefits for improving installations following a disaster instead of simply repairing or replacing them as they were prior to the disaster.
| Aug 11, 2010
City of Anaheim selects HOK Los Angeles and Parsons Brinckerhoff to design the Anaheim Regional Transportation Intermodal Center
The Los Angeles office of HOK, a global architecture design firm, and Parsons Brinckerhoff, a global infrastructure strategic consulting, engineering and program/construction management organization, announced its combined team was selected by the Anaheim City Council and Orange County Transportation Authority (OCTA) to design phase one of the Anaheim Regional Transportation Intermodal Center.
| Aug 11, 2010
GBCI launches credentialing maintenance program for current LEED APs
The Green Building Certification Institute (GBCI) launched a credentialing maintenance program (CMP) for LEED APs and Green Associates, ensuring that LEED professional credentials will remain relevant and meaningful in a rapidly evolving marketplace.
| Aug 11, 2010
Construction employment shrinks in 319 of the nation's 336 largest metro areas in July, continuing months-long slide
Construction workers in communities across the country continued to suffer extreme job losses this July according to a new analysis of metropolitan area employment data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics released today by the Associated General Contractors of America. That analysis found construction employment declined in 319 of the nation’s largest communities while only 11 areas saw increases and six saw no change in construction employment between July 2008 and July 2009.
| Aug 11, 2010
Green consultant guarantees LEED certification or your money back
With cities mandating LEED (Leadership in Energy and Environmental Design) certification for public, and even private, buildings in growing numbers, an Atlanta-based sustainability consulting firm is hoping to ease anxieties over meeting those goals with the industry’s first Green Guaranteed.
| Aug 11, 2010
Architecture Billings Index bounces back after substantial dip
Exhibiting a welcome rebound following a 5-point dip the month prior, the Architecture Billings Index (ABI) was up almost 6 points in July. As a leading economic indicator of construction activity, the ABI reflects the approximate nine to twelve month lag time between architecture billings and construction spending. The American Institute of Architects (AIA) reported the July ABI rating was 43.1, up noticeably from 37.7 the previous month.
| Aug 11, 2010
Rafael Vinoly-designed East Wing opens at Cleveland Museum of Art
Rafael Vinoly Architects has designed the new East Wing at the Cleveland Museum of Art (CMA), Ohio, which opened to the public on June 27, 2009. Its completion marks the opening of the first of three planned wings.