Value engineering brings Santa Barbara apartments back on track

When framing estimates for a new apartment complex in Rialto, California, came in too high, a savvy developer decided to have the project value engineered. A switch to glulam and wood-framed shear walls got the project back in the black. 

Sponsored content
November 11, 2016 |
Karyn Beebe

Watch the video to hear the developer and engineer describe how a switch to wood framing made this Rialto, California, project more affordable.

Although demand for housing in the area was rising rapidly, development of a new apartment complex in Rialto, California, had stalled. Estimates for the complex’s framing costs were coming in high, and the project just wasn’t penciling out. So the developer, Barbara Monroy of BM Investments Company, took a fresh look at the design of the project.

At the advice of her framing contractor, Monroy turned to Amir Deihimi, PE, of Core Structure, Inc., who helped identify ways to build the project more efficiently while maintaining the structural integrity of the buildings.

At seven buildings with 120 units altogether, this presented a challenge. Each building, at about 20,000 square feet each, is unique with one-, two- and three-bedroom apartments located above on-grade garages. Each garage has its own private stairway to the unit above.

“The Santa Barbara Complex is literally on top of a southern California fault line, so the seismic loads are significant,” said Deihimi. “But there are more affordable engineering solutions, and they had not been fully explored.”

Deihimi replaced expensive steel framing with I-joist compatible glulam and double-sided wood structural panel portal frames using force transfer around openings (FTAO), a method of shear wall analysis popular in California that cut costs drastically without cutting seismic performance.

Core Structure initially focused the value engineering process on the prefabricated steel shear walls. Each apartment has its own garage and in the original design, each garage had four steel shear walls (two back-to-back). To replace the expensive steel walls, Core Structure designed a cost-effective double-sided wood structural panel portal frame with force transfer around openings shear wall analysis. The same method was used around the entire exterior of the building at the window openings.

“The only thing we needed to add was the sheathing above and below the header,” said Deihimi. “And if we’re not doing that for shear, the framer has to fur it out anyway. Plus, the straps help us eliminate two hold-downs next to the opening. Often, those are HD-type hold-downs, which can be costly and difficult to install. But by using FTAO, we just ended up with a strap on each far end of the wall for this particular design.”

To learn more about the project and force transfer around openings (FTAO), visit Value Engineering on Designers Circle.

Karyn Beebe | APA Designers Circle: Projects and Practices
APA-The Engineered Wood Association
Engineered Wood Specialist

Karyn Beebe, PE, LEED AP is an Engineered Wood Specialist for APA-The Engineered Wood Association. Her duties include consulting with designers on the efficient specification of engineered wood products in construction. A licensed Professional Engineer in the state of California, Beebe graduated from Purdue University with a BS in Civil Engineering. She is an active member of the Structural Engineers Association and the U.S. Green Building Council, and serves as President for the San Diego Area Chapter of the ICC. Prior to joining APA, Beebe worked as a structural engineer and structural plan reviewer for the San Diego building department.

Related Blogs

​Image by Bob Narod

October 26, 2016 | Wood | APA Designers Circle: Projects and Practices

Fast-rising designers Ben Kasdan and Blake Jackson offer candid perspectives from both coasts on the merits...

October 13, 2016 | Wood | APA Designers Circle: Projects and Practices

Designers choose engineered wood to deliver strength, stability, and a sustainable solution for complex str...

August 22, 2016 | Building Materials | APA Designers Circle: Projects and Practices

Temporary Expansion Joints in Large Structures

July 21, 2016 | Energy Efficient Roofing | APA Designers Circle: Projects and Practices

Not all roof and ceiling assemblies are created equal, especially when it comes to energy performance.

July 05, 2016 | APA Designers Circle: Projects and Practices

Stronger building components combined with more intentionally constructed connections can mean the differen...

Compelling conversations about wood: Engineered wood as expressive design
December 07, 2015 | Wood | APA Designers Circle: Projects and Practices

This installment features a wide-ranging discussion that reveals how a mix of engineered wood products lend...

Schooling the visitor

The large CLT roof overhang is supported in part by 15-foot-tall concrete letters spelling “W-S-U” just outside of the high-ceilinged pavilion.

November 20, 2015 | APA Designers Circle: Projects and Practices

Exposed glulam and other engineered wood products help WSU tell its technology story

September 17, 2015 | Wood | APA Designers Circle: Projects and Practices

Architect Greg Mella and APA’s Karyn Beebe have a frank and far-reaching discussion about the tangibles and...

August 25, 2015 | Multifamily Housing | APA Designers Circle: Projects and Practices

Multifamily housing starts reached 358,000 in 2014, a 16 percent increase over 2013 and the highest total s...

Glulam provides aesthetic, structural, and safety solution for Appleton Mills project

Exterior of Appleton Mills at night.

July 29, 2015 | Building Materials | APA Designers Circle: Projects and Practices

The Appleton Mills complex includes 5 million square feet of space, with an original structure built in the...

Overlay Init