Sustainability rating systems: Are they doomed?

None of the hundreds of existing green building rating systems is perfect. Some of them are too documentation-heavy. Some increase short-term project cost. Some aren’t rigorous enough or include contentious issues, writes HDR's Michaella Wittmann.

September 15, 2014 |
HDR Insights

None of the hundreds of existing green building rating systems is perfect. Some of them are too documentation-heavy. Some increase short-term project cost. Some aren’t rigorous enough or include contentious issues.

But it would be extremely difficult to find many examples where the use of a sustainable rating system—whether actual certification was achieved or not—didn’t make the project better, either by shifting the way a project was discussed in terms of sustainability or inspiring a sustainable solution that brought value to the project.

I have worked on dozens of sustainability projects of all sizes, ranging from small non-profit office buildings to multi-billion dollar infrastructure projects. In all cases, if there wasn’t a commitment to a very specific sustainability goal, it was much harder to be sure that great sustainable solutions made it to the final design. Eventually I believe sustainability will rank right up there with schedule, cost, and design considerations in terms of priority, but for now, the topic is too often not afforded the same rigor.

At HDR, our philosophy is to drive sustainable solutions that are project-specific and bring value to our clients, communities and the environment. We want to know our clients’ specific priorities in terms of resource use, indoor environments, environmental impacts and the like. 

Can we provide that solution to them without the use of a rating system? Possibly, but I would argue that sustainability rating systems provide a framework to drive a discussion about sustainability and help assure that good solutions get implemented.

We are so sure that rating systems help drive culture shift and encourage project teams to ask the right questions that HDR has adopted High-Performance Sustainability Requirements (HPSRs). While not a rating system per se, these requirements represent a set of sustainability goals and conversations that we believe need to take place on all projects. The objective of HPSRs is to drive conversations about sustainability.

In the media, a lot of attention is currently being given to the problems with various systems and which rating system is best. Let’s improve the systems but acknowledge the market transformation that they have assisted in making.

About the Author

Michaella Wittmann is Director of Sustainable Solutions with HDR. She founded HDR’s sustainability program, and leads this initiative to encourage sustainability in all aspects of HDR—from our projects to our day-to-day business practices. That includes working on cool things like the greening of projects at the Pentagon and tracking HDR’s own carbon footprint. More on Wittmann.

 

Read more posts on the HDR BLiNK blog

HDR Insights | HDR
HDR

Our blogs are written by our employees at HDR. While we are most well-known for delivering architecture and engineering services—for adding beauty and structure to communities through high performance buildings and smart infrastructure, we provide much more than that. We create an unshakable foundation for progress because our multidisciplinary teams also include scientists, economists, builders, analysts and artists. Our thought leader bloggers represent offices from around the world and write about ideas, experiences and insights into our practice and the greater design community. Come visit us at Insights @hdrinc.com.

Related Blogs

April 04, 2017 | Building Team | HDRJeri Brittin, Director of Research, HDR

Many assume that post-occupancy (POE) is a clearly-defined term and concept, but the meaning of POE in prac...

March 24, 2017 | Healthcare Facilities | HDRJoel Worthington & Beth Zacherle

Pediatric experience design must evolve beyond the common mantra of “make it fun” or “make it look kid-frie...

January 19, 2017 | Sustainability | HDRJennifer Bienemann, Environmental Engineer, HDR

To help one of the most complex cities in the world develop an actionable strategy to meet visionary GHG re...

October 21, 2016 | Architects | HDRLynn Mignola, Strategic Facilities Planner

Sometimes people look only for the simple answer and don’t understand that there is a calculated process to...

Pixabay Public Domain

October 03, 2016 | HDRJoel Worthington, Strategic Innovation Designer

Know what you're working toward, be empathetic, and listen actively are three tips HDR's Joel Worthington s...

September 08, 2016 | Sustainability | HDRLynn Mignola

When it comes to design we are in the business of imagining what could be, not necessarily what is, writes...

Courtesy of HDR

August 10, 2016 | Healthcare Facilities | HDRBrian Zabloudil, Healthcare Planner

Engagement at all levels, designing with families in mind, and integrating flexible spaces are all importan...

Images courtesy HDR

June 14, 2016 | Office Building Design | HDRLynn Mignola

Recent design trends favor extroverts who enjoy collaboration. HDR's Lynn Mignola says that designers need...

How HDR used computational design tools to design Omaha's UNO Baxter Arena

The new Baxter Arena in Omaha, Neb. Photo: Dan Schwalm, courtesy of HDR Architecture, Inc. Click here to enlarge.

May 02, 2016 | BIM and Information Technology | HDRMatt Goldsberry

Three years after writing a white paper about designing an arena for the University of Nebraska Omaha, HDR'...

Identifying, using, and applying predictive analytics

Photo: Jeff Seeger/Creative Commons

March 28, 2016 | Big Data | HDRBranden Collingsworth

Branden Collingsworth, HDR’s new Director of Predictive Analytics, clarifies what his team does and how arc...

Overlay Init