Planning and constructing a hybrid operating room: Lessons learned

A Hybrid operating room (OR) is an OR that is outfitted with advanced imaging equipment that allows surgeons, radiologists, and other providers to use real-time images for guidance and assessment while performing complex surgeries.

December 07, 2018 |
NACLab Blog

On average, 51 Million surgical inpatient procedures are performed in the United States each year. With the increased focus on wellness, preventative, and team-based medicine, an introduction of new technology, and a change to patient outcome-based reimbursement, many traditional surgical procedures are evolving.

Our healthcare clients are continuously looking for ways to improve service delivery and offer the highest quality of care for their patients. As an architecture firm, we diligently track healthcare trends and emerging best practices to offer our clients cutting-edge design solutions that meet their program and operational needs, increase efficiencies, and enhance the patient experience. One trend that is quickly gaining momentum as an effective way to maximize procedural benefits and improve patient outcomes is hybrid operating rooms.

 

Hybrid Operating Rooms

3D model of the hybrid OR at Kootenai Health – NAC Architecture. Image courtesy of Stryker

A Hybrid operating room (OR) is an OR that is outfitted with advanced imaging equipment that allows surgeons, radiologists, and other providers to use real-time images for guidance and assessment while performing complex surgeries. A typical OR can use mobile imaging equipment, however it does not produce the high quality images that are needed for delicate procedures. A true hybrid OR will include a built-in C-arm X-ray, CT, or MRI machine.

By using this high resolution real-time imaging, hybrid ORs allow for more accurate and less invasive surgical procedures which lead to quicker patient recovery. Procedures that historically would require open-heart surgery can be accomplished with a minimally invasive interventional procedure, potentially reducing the recovery time by several weeks.

Not only is there a recovery time benefit to the patient, but safety during the procedure is also another advantage. If an emergency arises during an interventional procedure, it can quickly be revised to be an open procedure since the room is set up as a fully functional OR. No critical time is lost in changing equipment or transporting the patient to a different operating room.

The types of procedures performed in a hybrid OR are typically cardiac, vascular, and neurosurgery, but the variety and number of procedures is growing rapidly. When designing these types of facilities, it is critical to determine the primary use of the hybrid OR early in the decision making process.

 

C-arm X-ray installations are the most common equipment installed in hybrid operating Rooms. Kootenai Health – NAC Architecture Case Study: Kootenai Health Surgery Renovation.

 

Case Study: Kootenai Health Surgery Renovation

The multi-phase surgery renovation for Kootenai Health updated every square foot of the surgery department, including eight traditional operating rooms and one hybrid operating room.

 

Lessons Learned

Location, location, location. The location of the hybrid OR is critical; its efficiency depends on strategic placement. The procedures performed in the room will determine the location relative to other hospital functions, the equipment type needed, room size, patient and staff flow, and many more factors.

 

Space planning diagram for a hybrid OR. Kootenai Health – NAC Architecture. 

 

A hybrid OR was a high priority in Kootenai’s surgery renovation, but the initial funding did not include the build-out of the room. When the final decision to move forward with the hybrid room was made, the room that had initially been reserved for the hybrid OR had to be relocated to be adjacent to critical departments. Kootenai’s hybrid OR is primarily used for cardiac and vascular procedures, which required it to be in close proximity to the existing heart center, cath labs, and cardiovascular operating rooms. This revision required a shuffle of spaces after construction had started and many constraints were in place.

Every Square Foot Counts. Code requires a traditional operating room to have a minimum clear floor area of 400 square feet. A hybrid OR is required to be 1.5x as large, with a minimum clear floor area of 600 square feet. Because hybrid ORs require additional space for equipment and to provide flexibility for the types of procedures performed, these rooms typically average more than 1,000 square feet.

Due to existing constraints at Kootenai Health, the hybrid OR was limited to 715 square feet. While this is in excess of code minimum, it did require meticulous planning to ensure there was adequate space for imaging and surgical equipment, while still allowing a functional operating room.

 

Key Technologies Needed in Hybrid ORs Include:
Fixed angiographic imaging system Heart-lung bypass machine
Hybrid operating table Physiologic / hemodynamic monitor
Wall- and boom-mounted video display monitors Contrast injector
Surgical and interventional lighting Transthoracic and intravascular echo
Anesthesia machine Surgical carts and storage systems

 

Functionality is Key. In-depth coordination and planning is critical to ensure the equipment in the hybrid OR is correctly located and functional. Hybrid OR suites are comprised of up to 100 different medical devices and systems from multiple vendors.1 

Kootenai Health selected a Philips Allura ceiling-mounted C-arm and Stryker booms, lights, and integration system. With four boom mounts that each contained multiple arms, the coordination between Philips and Stryker was essential. To function as an OR, laminar diffusers and lighting needed to be centered over the table. The fixed rails and mobile trolley for the C-arm created a large no-fly zone over the center of the room. This no-fly zone forces the boom mounts to be located towards the outside of the room and requires long arms to allow the lights and monitors to be brought to the correct location.

 

An integrated ceiling system in a hybrid OR houses all overhead equipment in a modular, prefabricated system. This minimizes conflicts with ductwork and utilities. Kootenai Health – NAC Architecture.

 

Ceiling Height: Height requirement in a hybrid OR is similar to a typical OR, but there is additional equipment and light booms to support. A ceiling mounted imaging system will compound the above-ceiling supports required. The floor-to-floor height should be a minimum of 15'. <>The existing structure at Kootenai Health’s hybrid location has a 17' floor-to-floor height. Even with this large interstitial space, supporting several booms and the large overhead imaging system still posed a challenge. Accommodating each individually would result in a maze of structural supports and braces that would make it extremely difficult to coordinate with the HVAC ductwork. The solution was to use an integrated ceiling system by SLD Technology. This system integrates the laminar flow diffuser, room lighting, boom support mounts, and even the support for the C-arm imaging equipment, all in a modular prefabricated system. The low profile and minimal field connections allowed ample room for existing ductwork and utilities to remain in place.

Imaging Requirements: Each type of imaging equipment will have its own specific room requirements, such as lead shielding for the C-arm. The lead shielding detailing and installation for an OR is similar to a typical x-ray room, requiring a physicist's shielding design and construction using lead-lined gyp bd., doors & relites, and lead protection at all penetrations.

 

In addition to the actual operating area, a hybrid OR required a separate control room and equipment room, which adds to the necessary square footage. Kootenai Health – NAC Architecture.

 

An OR may have additional equipment that is not standard in a typical x-ray room, such as the pass-through blanket warming cabinets located between the OR and the sterile core in Kootenai’s typical ORs. While lead-lined pass-thru warming cabinets are available, the desire to have standardized equipment manufacturers meant that the pass-through was revised to be a free-standing warming cabinet for the hybrid OR.

 

The Future of Hybrid ORs

The hybrid operating room is essential for multi-disciplinary integration in the OR, combining diagnostics and surgery using a team of specialists, creating true team-based healthcare. As technology increases and more surgeries can be performed with minimally invasive interventional procedures, hybrid operating rooms continue to become more popular. These rooms will become standard in operating suites for new facilities. Incorporating hybrid ORs into existing structures will continue to be a challenge, which will require open communication, collaboration, acute attention to detail, and an experienced design team.

 

References

1 ECRI Institute (2015). Hybrid Operating Rooms. Retrieved from https://www.ecri.org/Documents/ White_papers/Hybrid_OR_MS15532.pdf

NACLab Blog | NAC Architecture
NAC Architecture

NAC Architecture is an award-winning design firm, with over 170 professionals and a track record spanning more than half a century. We are thought leaders, yet our legacy of listening and learning remains constant. The NACLab, NAC Architecture’s blog, features thoughts and lessons related to current issues. Authored by our established and emerging thought leaders, the purpose of the blog is to invite conversation and constructive reflection on the cultural and material complexities of design. We believe this dialogue ultimately informs stronger design solutions to our clients’ and society’s most challenging problems. Visit us at http://www.nacarchitecture.com/NACLab/default.aspx.

Related Blogs

November 07, 2018 | Healthcare Facilities | NAC ArchitectureJill Kurtz, AIA, NCARB, Senior Associate and Marcia Wall, ASID, Senior Associate

How can architecture decrease frustration, increase the feeling of self-worth, and increase the ability to...

October 08, 2018 | University Buildings | NAC ArchitectureRon van der Veen, FAIA, LEED AP, Principal

While the programming and design for these buildings all kept a holistic living/learning experience at the...

September 12, 2018 | Education Facility | NAC ArchitectureMichael Pinto, AIA, Principal and Randy Wilson, AIA, LEED AP Principal

In order to effectively talk about school design, we need to start by understanding what a school is design...

July 06, 2018 | Education Facility | NAC ArchitectureTeresa Alvarado and Philip Riedel

Today, efforts toward equity in education encompass a wide spectrum of considerations including sex, gender...

May 29, 2018 | Healthcare Facilities | NAC ArchitectureDaniel C. Jardine, Principal, AIA, LEED AP

Telemedicine is a broad term that covers many aspects and mediums of care, but primarily it refers to the u...

March 23, 2018 | Education Facility | NAC ArchitectureEmily Spillar, Associate IIDA

In order to understand why a school day can be so grueling for an introverted student, it’s important to kn...

October 31, 2017 | K-12 Schools | NAC ArchitectureSean Joyner

People are enigmatic and inherently complex, which can make it difficult to design for a larger population....

Children at play in an early education center classroom
October 03, 2017 | Education Facility | NAC ArchitectureMelissa A. McFadgen and Helena L. Jubany

When the design of early learning centers is grounded in the science of developmental psychology and educat...

Children working on laptops
September 12, 2017 | NAC ArchitectureLarry Kearns, Principal, FAIA / LEED AP and Timothy A. Ballard AIA / LEED AP / PRINCIPAL

Simply defined, blended learning mixes face-to-face with online instruction.

Cherry Crest Elementary School, Bellevue, Wash. Photo: NAC Architecture

March 09, 2017 | K-12 Schools | NAC ArchitectureMatthew Rumbaugh, AIA, LEED AP, Design Principal, NAC Architecture

The art of designing schools lies not in just understanding what makes a functional classroom, but in how s...

Overlay Init