flexiblefullpage -
billboard - default
interstitial1 - interstitial
catfish1 - bottom
Currently Reading

Modular adaptive reuse of parking structure grants future flexibility

Adaptive Reuse

Modular adaptive reuse of parking structure grants future flexibility

Design concept Park House 2.0 suggests the adaptive reuse conversion of an underutilized parking garage into multifamily units using modular construction.

By Marissa Kasdan, Associate AIA | KTGY | May 15, 2024
Park House 2.0 adaptive reuse project exterior rendering
The Park House 2.0 concept studied modification to an existing parking structure, addition of residential units, and appropriate construction sequencing. Rendering courtesy KTGY

What do Buffalo, N.Y.; Hartford, Conn.; and San Jose, Calif., have in common? Beginning with Buffalo in 2017, all have abolished parking minimums as a requirement for new residential development. Last November, Austin, Texas, followed suit, eliminating parking requirements for new development, with an exception for accessible parking.

The shift away from excessive parking requirements aligns with a broader movement, encouraging development of more sustainable and affordable housing. According to engineering firm WGI, a single parking space in a parking structure costs roughly $28,000—an additional expense many households would choose to forego, if given the opportunity.

With rising housing costs outpacing salary increases, renters and homeowners alike are looking for solutions that reduce their housing expenses. Separating the cost of parking from housing provides flexibility for managing tight household budgets.

Adaptive Reuse of Parking Structure into new Multifamily Community

Changes in jurisdictional parking requirements provide opportunities for reduced cost of future housing, but residential buildings developed over the last 20 years may already experience the burden of excess parking resulting from past requirements. Particularly in transit-oriented communities, oversized parking structures may be underused.

Additionally, many communities have seen recent expansions of mass transit systems, further decreasing the need for personal vehicles. From Loudon County, Va., outside of Washington, D.C., to the suburbs of Seattle, Wash., new and planned expansion of transit services provide much-needed connectivity, evolving previously car-dependent neighborhoods into transit-oriented communities.

With consideration for changes in driving habits, as well as the widespread concern for housing costs, KTGY’s Research and Development Studio designed a housing concept in 2017 that proposed adaptive reuse of a free-standing parking structure adjacent to a multifamily wrap building. The design concept, Park House, suggested converting underutilized parking into residential units using modular construction.

Modular adaptive reuse housing project cross section rendering
Rendering courtesy KTGY

The concept studied modification to the existing parking structure, addition of residential units, and appropriate construction sequencing. The Park House concept addressed many common adaptive reuse challenges, such as modifications to the structural system and incorporation of utilities, using a complete-conversion approach, with all construction occurring within a single modification timeline.

After discussing this strategy with multifamily developers and operators, complete conversion seemed difficult to justify when only a portion of the garage was unused. While cities pull back on parking requirements rapidly, driving habits change more gradually.

In 2023, with feedback from experts in the industry, KTGY’s Research and Development Studio created an alternative solution for converting underutilized parking to residential using a phased approach. Park House 2.0 proposes an adaptive reuse solution that converts a single floor of underutilized parking at a time, leaving room for further conversion in the future, as market demands shift.

Park House 2.0 Adaptive Reuse Process

Beginning with an existing wrap-building garage from a KTGY project in San Jose, Calif., Park House 2.0 proposes removing the highest level of the parking ramp and inserting wood-framed residential units into the flat portions of that level. The central ramp, now encircled by units, becomes a community courtyard.

Modular platforms create flat areas for outdoor amenity programming along a walkway winding down the existing ramp. Utility chases constructed vertically along the exterior façade during the initial phase of conversion resolve potential conflicts between utilities and remaining lower-level parking.

Park House 2.0 phasing chart

Structural modifications also take place during the initial phase of conversion, replacing shear walls adjacent to the parking ramp with brace and moment frames, accounting for the future addition of units in those locations.

As residents require fewer parking spaces, the next highest level of the parking ramp is removed and wood-framed units are added, plugging in to the pre-built utility chases. The modular platforms on the sloped amenity ramp shift down to the next lower level of the garage ramp, bringing the amenity courtyard to the lowest residential level.

The Goal of Flexibility

Over the last few years, housing trends have driven residential architecture to incorporate more and more flexibility—in interior unit design, in amenity space functionality, and in ownership options. Increased flexibility can help housing reach a wider demographic and adapt to cultural shifts. But if the goal of incorporating flexibility is to add value for stakeholders, taking a step back and examining flexibility in adaptive reuse solutions creates additional value for underutilized spaces now, and for the future.

Park House 2.0 amenity breakdown drawing


Rendering of adaptive reuse multifamily project
Amenity breakdown at Park House 2.0. Rendering courtesy KTGY

More from Author

KTGY | Apr 13, 2024

Former industrial marina gets adaptive reuse treatment

At its core, adaptive reuse is an active reimagining of the built environment in ways that serve the communities who use it. Successful adaptive reuse uncovers the latent potential in a place and uses it to meet people’s present needs.

KTGY | Apr 8, 2024

3 sustainable design decisions to make early

In her experience as an architect, Megan Valentine AIA, LEED AP, NCARB, WELL AP, Fitwel, Director of Sustainability, KTGY has found three impactful sustainable design decisions: site selection, massing and orientation, and proper window-to-wall ratios.

KTGY | Aug 24, 2023

A multifamily design for multigenerational living

KTGY’s Family Flat concept showcases the benefits of multigenerational living through a multifamily design lens.

KTGY | Jul 27, 2023

Repeatable, supportive housing for the unhoused

KTGY’s R+D concept, The Essential, rethinks supportive housing to support the individual and community with a standardized and easily repeatable design.

boombox1 - default
boombox2 -
native1 -

More In Category

MFPRO+ Special Reports

Top 10 trends in affordable housing

Among affordable housing developers today, there’s one commonality tying projects together: uncertainty. AEC firms share their latest insights and philosophies on the future of affordable housing in BD+C's 2023 Multifamily Annual Report.

halfpage1 -

Most Popular Content

  1. 2021 Giants 400 Report
  2. Top 150 Architecture Firms for 2019
  3. 13 projects that represent the future of affordable housing
  4. Sagrada Familia completion date pushed back due to coronavirus
  5. Top 160 Architecture Firms 2021