Free transit for everyone! Then again, maybe not

An interesting experiment is taking place in Tallinn, the capital of Estonia, where, for the last year or so, its 430,000 residents have been able to ride the city’s transit lines practically for free. City officials hope to pump up ridership by 20%, cut carbon emissions, and give low-income Tallinnites greater access to job opportunities. But is it working?

March 26, 2014 |
Rob Cassidy

Tallinn, Estonia. Photo: Diego Delso, Wikimedia Commons, License CC-BY-SA 3.0

Most workdays, I ride the commuter train to my office. It’s a pleasant, half-hour trip, and I almost always get to stretch out on a seat made for two. Due to my advanced senectitude, I pay half-fare; with the tax writeoff of my flexible spending account, I save even more. But here’s the kicker: I’d pay full fare if I had to.

Sure, it’s nice to be “subsidized,” but I don’t need the handout. I’d ride the rails to work just to avoid the traffic—and get a half hour to proofread copy and think.

I bring this up in the context of an interesting experiment that’s taking place in Tallinn, the capital of Estonia, where, for the last year or so, its 430,000 residents have been able to ride the city’s transit lines practically for free (there’s a  €2 signup fee; tourists still pay the €1.60 fare).

According to Sulev Vedler, writing in CityScope magazine, city officals hoped to pump up ridership by 20%, cut carbon emissions, and give low-income Tallinnites greater access to job opportunities.

Tallinn, with roughly the same population as Omaha, Neb., and Raleigh, N.C., follows on the heels of Templin (Germany), Aubagne (France), and Hasselt (Belgium), all of which have tried free transit, with varying degrees of success.

In the U.S., several cities with major universities—Chapel Hill, N.C.; Minneapolis–St. Paul; Stanford, Calif.; and Corvallis, Ore.—offer free rides, as do some small communities like Commerce, Calif. (pop. 12,823), Vero Beach, Fla., (15,527), and Mason County, Wash. (60,999). 

Back to Tallinn: How’s the noble experiment doing? Depends on who you ask.

The mayor of Tallinn says transit ridership is up substantially, and traffic congestion “at major crossroads” (Vedler’s phrase) is down 14%.

But researchers at Sweden’s Royal Institute of Technology who are studying Tallinn’s program say it’s more like a 3% blip in ridership, and that more than half of that can be attributed to service improvements and new bus priority lanes. In fact, the Swedish scientists found that traffic flow had not improved, as would be expected if there were fewer cars on the street.

Moreover, the Swedes reported that some Tallinnites were hopping on the tram instead of walking a few blocks—not a good prospect for the population’s future kilo count.

The researchers did, however, find that transit ridership in a high-unemployment neighborhood of Tallinn was up 10%. Whether this was helping the locals get to good jobs has not been proven.

The problem with applying the Tallinn experience to big cities in the U.S., Europe, or Asia is that Tallinn’s trams and buses were already subsidized to the tune of 70%; now it’s 96%. On most systems, fare collections pay for a huge chunk of operating costs: on my train line, it’s 50%; in London, fares cover 85% of ops costs.

If people won’t flock to transit with the lure of a free ride, what will get them on the bus? From my experience, comfort, quality of service, and convenience of schedule are, within reason, more important than low fares. 

As America’s metro areas get more and more dense, our ability to move people and goods efficiently and affordably will become even more problematic. Your clients need to know that their customers will have ready access to the retail stores, offices, hospitals, schools—whatever—that you’re designing and building for them.

Until the happy day when everyone gets a free ride, though, don’t mess with my subsidies!

Rob Cassidy | BD+C Editors

Robert Cassidy is Executive Editor of Building Design+Construction. A city planner, he is the author of several books, including “Livable Cities,” and was a co-founder of the Friends of the Chicago River.

Related Blogs

Annual mortgage payment plus property tax per average square foot of housing in US cities.

Source: World Business Chicago

April 30, 2018 | Multifamily Housing | BD+C EditorsRobert Cassidy

It's inaccurate to focus on property taxes as a percentage of home value without acknowledging the actual c...

MIT’s Simmons Hall, designed by Steven Holl

MIT’s Simmons Hall, designed by Steven Holl

January 05, 2018 | Big Data | BD+C EditorsDavid Barista, Editorial Director

At a time when research- and data-based methods are playing a larger role in architecture, there remains a...

Illustration: Pixabay

December 30, 2016 | Building Team | BD+C Editors

Women AEC professionals need you to take action. 

Lissette Méndez-Boyer (left) and Natalya Shimanovskaya work on their FABRICation project at Beyer Blinder Belle’s New York office. Photo courtesy BBB

September 06, 2016 | AEC Tech | BD+C Editors

AEC firms are taking a page from the tech industry, by infusing a deep commitment to innovation and disrupt...

Intel Co-founders (l. to r.): Andrew Grove, Robert Noyce, and Gordon Moore. Photo: Wikimedia Commons   

June 27, 2016 | AEC Tech | BD+C Editors

“Sooner or later, something fundamental in your business world will change.” The late Andrew Grove (1936-20...

Photo: Mass Communications Specialist 1st Class Corey Lewis , U.S. Navy, via Wikimedia Commons; photo filter via

May 31, 2016 | AEC Tech | BD+C Editors

As buildings become increasingly connected, opportunistic hackers have countless avenues into a building’s...

Lexus RX 450h self-driving car. Photo: Wikimedia Commons

May 09, 2016 | AEC Tech | BD+C Editors

Despite popular belief, the country is not in a great age of technological and digital innovation, at least...

Deep Learning + AI: How machines are becoming master problem solvers

The world’s top Go player Lee Sedol puts the first stone against Google’s artificial intelligence program AlphaGo during the third match of the Google DeepMind Challenge match in Seoul, South Korea. Photo: Reuters/Google/Yonhap

March 31, 2016 | AEC Tech | BD+C Editors

Besides revolutionary changes to the world’s workforce, artificial intelligence could have a profound impac...

Yotel, New York City. Photo: JasonParis, flickr creative commons

March 09, 2016 | Hotel Facilities | BD+C EditorsRobert Cassidy, Executive Editor

Hotels are going for a new minimalist look to attract younger guests, but some older business travelers don...

Is the booming freelance economy a threat to AEC firms?

Photo: Pixabay

February 24, 2016 | Architects | BD+C Editors

By shifting the work (and revenue) to freelancers, “platform capitalism” startups have taken considerable m...

Overlay Init