Designing campus buildings through an equity lens

As colleges become more diverse, campus conversation is focusing on how to create equitable environments that welcome all voices.

March 09, 2020 |
HGA Insights Blog

Traditionally, campuses have been designed for the able-bodied, college-age student from the majority culture who enrolls full-time. But today’s campuses—from residential to commuter, four-year to community college, research to liberal arts—are now serving students from a wider demographic with a broader range of life experiences.

Campuses are responding to these changing demographics through a range of inclusive initiatives. The built environment is one of the most powerful expressions of an institution’s values and often must change to communicate that all are welcome. But campuses are still unsure how to translate equity into the facility planning process and communicate inclusivity through architecture.

How do campuses throw open the doors to become truly welcoming? Several recent projects offer encouraging possibilities—reinforcing the motto that has long served disability rights advocates: “Nothing about us without us.”

 

Student Visioning at UVA

For a feasibility study at the University of Virginia (UVA) in Charlottesville, a team of students, architects, and ethnographic researchers helped redefine the role of UVA’s aging Student Activities Building (SAB) serving student-led arts and cultural activities in the context of the campus Grounds. Applying a variety of ethnographic and digital spatial-mapping tools to track student activity in and around SAB and adjacent buildings, the research team—consisting of more than 200 students over a four-month period—evaluated primary data to co-create several design options in two ideation workshops to boost SAB as a multipurpose hub for student groups, meetings, and events.

Significantly, the project placed students at the forefront of the planning process, engaging a diverse group of student body representatives and student leaders in focus-group and town-hall discussions alongside consulting architects, the Facilities Planner with the Office of the Architect, and the Assistant Vice President of Student Affairs.

As a key finding early on, the group determined that the student committee needed to be expanded significantly and the process needed to increase transparency to be truly inclusive of all users of the building. Students took the lead in bringing more varied voices to the table. The result was to engage students in the programming and design of the project at a variety of scales to draw them in and make it clear that their voices were valued, and their creativity and insight could make an impact. Through their involvement, they showed that it would be possible to welcome and create more interaction among students from diverse backgrounds by expanding the building program from a single-use facility to one that supports multiple concurrent uses.

 

Gender Equity at Cornell

In another instance at Cornell University in Ithaca, New York, students and administrators identified the need for a new Rowing Center on Lake Cayuga to accommodate its growing Men’s Heavyweight, Men’s Lightweight, and Women’s rowing teams.

The original rowing facilities included the two-story Collyer Boathouse built for the men’s teams in the 1950s, and an adjacent one-story Robison Boathouse added for the women’s team in the 1970s—with men and women sharing the training room on the second level of the men’s facility.

The boathouses lacked amenities to fully support the growing teams and gender equity. For instance, to access the training room in Collyer, women had to enter through an exterior stairwell or go through the men’s locker room. Additionally, the women’s crew had tripled since the 1970s, yet the locker rooms were one-third the size of the men’s locker room.

Planning sessions stressed gender equity and elevating the rowing program’s overall campus visibility. As such, the design solution repurposed the two facilities, adding a two-story addition to Collyer that included separate locker rooms for the three teams; converting the first floor of Collyer into an expansive entrance lobby and gathering space; upgrading and expanding the second-floor multipurpose training room into a bright and welcoming space with equal access; and repurposing Robison into equipment storage.

The result is a rowing program that architecturally places men and women’s teams on equal footing while inviting the wider campus to participate in events, creating a waterfront destination that identifies Cornell Rowing as a distinct brand.

 

Inclusive Experiences

Designing from an equity lens also considers how to make the campus experience as seamless as possible for people with special needs. Many campuses, for instance, have art museums and performing-arts centers, designed generally for the able-bodied student. But how, for instance, does someone with vision impairment enjoy an art exhibit?

The Wharton Esherick Museum in Malvern, Pennsylvania, has proposed one solution with its Touch Tour, a specially designed tour of the museum that encourages attendees to touch the namesake’s wood-crafted artwork—often taboo in most exhibits.

 

 

HGA created a touch model of Esherick’s home and studio so that visitors with limited vision can finally experience the largest piece in the museum’s collection—the very building in which the piece were built and that houses the work today. The lesson learned in this process is that heightened interpretive experiences for one type of user can often help all users. In this case, visitors with full sight can learn more about Wharton Esherick’s work as well through use of the touch model.

Campuses themselves can find lessons here to think creatively about staging interactive exhibits and events that encourage fresh perspectives. A vision-impaired student can enjoy an exhibit while inviting sighted students to experience a unique viewpoint—encouraging inclusion for all.

 

Looking Forward

Designing from an equity lens is about listening without assumptions and creating experiences that all can share. When approaching your next campus project, consider these suggestions:

Identify Stakeholders—Start by identifying your stakeholder groups, thinking broadly about who they are and how to expand the potential pool beyond traditional committee makeup. Committees tend to be heavy on administrators, faculty members, and standout students but light on truly representative students—especially those who by choice stay at the margins. Inclusion can change the outcomes, and certainly will provide experiences that change the students’ relationship to the institution.

Engage Stakeholders—Create dialogue, visioning, and ideation sessions that integrate distinct voices. Surprising and delightful ideas may percolate.

Reverse Roles—Shed preconceived notions about user groups and look at a potential project from another’s eyes. As with the Touch Tour, all can experience something unique by seeing through the lens of another.

By approaching design through an equity lens, the phrase “all are welcome” can truly resonate on campus.

HGA Insights Blog
HGA Insights Blog
HGA

HGA is a national multidisciplinary design firm rooted in architecture and engineering. We believe that the best design results from deep insight into the people and passions that animate each unique environment. More than 850 people in 11 offices from coast to coast work to make a positive, lasting impact for clients in healthcare, arts and culture, community, corporate, education, government, science and technology, and energy markets. Read HGA’s Insights Blog here: https://hga.com/insights/.

Overlay Init