Creating communities from defunct malls

It’s time to plan for the suburban retail reset—and it starts by rethinking the traditional mall.

June 21, 2017 |
Stantec Blog

“Stores are closing at an epic pace. In fact, the retail industry could suffer far more store closures this year than ever.” — CNN, 4/24/17

It’s no secret that suburban retailing is in crisis. At the current pace, more stores will close in 2017than at the height of the Great Recession. As store vacancies—and lost tax revenues for local communities—mount, so do disinvestment, blight, and crime. Nowhere is this more visible than in the hundreds of struggling malls across the US.

Everyone blames online retailing for these problems, but in fact those purchases accounted for only about 8 percent of all U.S. retail sales in the fourth quarter of 2016. A more likely culprit: overbuilding. The US averages 7.3- square feet of retail per capita, compared to 1.7 square feet in Japan and 1.3 square feet in the UK. Online does pose a real threat (one analyst says that “50 percent of all retail not tied to bars and restaurants will go online by 2030”), but we already have more big boxes than we know what to do with.

Many of the areas around faltering malls face another serious threat: an oversupply of single-family housing and a dearth of high-quality, multi-family rentals. Millennials and empty nesters alike are choosing more urban, walkable environments. You may have read about this happening in cities, but it’s happening in suburban settings, too. These folks don’t want a house, and they want fewer cars, in part because the cost of car ownership has reached $8,700 annually. Times are changing … quickly.

For the suburbs of the 1960s and ’70s, typically built on previously undeveloped farmland, malls served as town centers and community gathering places. But as decades passed, piecemeal development turned the areas around them into traffic-choked seas of parking lots and drive-in businesses with no center.

A growing number of US communities have begun actively thinking about how to reinvent these locations as distinct, authentic districts. Yes, the automobile—and the all-consuming parking spaces that go with them—will remain (for now) but dramatic transformation is still possible. We’ve had the good fortune recently to work with two municipalities that have taken the lead in shaping their futures by rethinking the traditional mall.

 

Planning from the outside in

Ohio’s Miami Township, south of Dayton, faces a unique challenge. While the area suffers from the issues touched on above—store closings, aging buildings, auto-dependent development, and a lack of connections among adjacent land uses—the mall itself is a regional destination that remains relatively healthy. The focus of the plan quickly became one of creating a district around the mall that would improve the entire 2 square miles of the study area. 

 

Lyon's ridge shopping plaza

 

During the planning process, community members frequently said how much they enjoyed walking within the mall in fall and winter. The master plan creates a new Main Street along the eastern edge of the mall that crosses the current Sears site, which will shortly close. That will set up a direct intersection with the mall’s internal Main Street, creating a new focus for the area. 

 

Dayton mall main streets diagram

 

High-visibility signs of disinvestment made the entire district feel rundown and worn-out. In addition, the name “Dayton Mall Area” conveyed no sense of identity or location. Therefore, our plan for the area around the mall also included establishing it as a defined—and branded—district. The new name, “Miami Crossing,” gives a poorly defined area a clear identity; the marketing plan reinforces the new identify with signage, banners, and distinctive landscaping at key gateways.

 

Miami crossing banner on a light post

 

Planning from the inside out

The Route 419 Town Center Study in Roanoke, Virginia, had similar planning goals: conversion of auto-oriented strip development into a mixed-use, walkable town center. In this instance, however, the Tanglewood Mall has been unable to compete with a larger regional mall 20 minutes away. New owners bought the property just before the planning effort began, and they understood that the property couldn’t count on a future as a traditional, enclosed mall. They actively took part in the planning process and helped us develop a concept that deconstructed much of the mall interior while preserving anchor tenants. This may seem like a side story, but in most malls the anchor tenants control parking and view sheds, and they often have a say in which stores can (or cannot) locate in the mall. The mall owner frequently has only limited control in determining the property’s future.

All sides understood that entertainment- and experience-based retail (think sit-down restaurants with outdoor seating within an easy walk of local or boutique retailers) will define future success. That helped our team create a small-town center where the enclosed mall will give way to a wider mix of uses, including new housing, an inviting landscaped open space, and a network of new landscaped streets that invite walking and improve connectivity across the district. 

 

Rendering of outdoor shopping plaza with greenspace

 

What the future looks like

The upheaval in retail and shopping preferences presents many challenges, but it can also prod everyone to take a fresh look at traditional suburban development patterns. Miami Township and Roanoke County show that local leaders don’t have to wait for outside forces to reshape them; they can shape the future by pulling property owners, nearby residents, and other stakeholders together to chart a new course for the community.

Stantec Blog | Stantec
Stantec

Published by global design firm Stantec, this eclectic blog features viewpoints, insights, and explanations from Stantec architects, engineers, and designers, on a range of issues impacting the fabric of our communities. Our contributors share their thoughts about design trends, emerging technologies, vexing challenges, and inspired solutions. For more blog posts, visit: www.stantec.com.

Related Blogs

September 24, 2018 | Architects | StantecMike Gervasi

While offering efficiency and flexibility, modular construction requires extensive planning and collaborati...

August 15, 2018 | Green | StantecNels Nelson

The WELL Community Standard equips planners to build health promotion into the very fabric of neighborhoods...

An apartment-style student housing project uses patterning and window placement to generate interest on an otherwise flat façade

July 13, 2018 | Multifamily Housing | StantecBryan Morrison

While student and multi-family housing share a common building form, it’s the student resident that drives...

June 18, 2018 | Urban Planning | StantecJoe Geller

Five years ago, experts were predicting continued urban rebound and suburban decline. What really happened?...

April 18, 2018 | Sustainability | StantecHeather Greene

The future office strives to be better, focus more on the people who inhabit it, and contribute to the succ...

April 09, 2018 | Sustainability | StantecTravis Sage

Imagine a future where buildings and infrastructure are 100% utilized and 100% responsive.

March 02, 2018 | Office Building Design | StantecJenya Guillemin

These days, if your office space isn’t a true reflection of your brand, you’ve missed a big opportunity to...

Our team helped implement public improvements along 1,500 feet of Wisconsin shoreline. This project benefited from community outreach.

February 26, 2018 | Urban Planning | StantecLindsey Christopherson

A new community engagement program works with young adults to help the future of the neighborhood and get o...

November 15, 2017 | Resiliency | StantecBlake Jackson

The developer sees resilient developments achieving top-of-market pricing, faster leasing, higher renewal,...

October 25, 2017 | Healthcare Facilities | StantecDouglas King, Senior Associate, Stantec

Children often accompany parents or grandparents in medical settings; what can we do to address their uniqu...

Overlay Init