Changing the way we think about water and design

We have several gaps between the need and desire to have abundant, accessible, clean water and the reality of dealing with on-going and increasing water shortage crises.

June 04, 2018 |
DLR Group Insights Blog

At the recent Living Future Conference and the Colorado State University Water Symposium, I was struck by the global challenge we face in how we use, conserve, and think about water. In fact, these conferences presented big ideas related to water resourcing and inspired me to brainstorm ways we can gain momentum through meaningful, long-term change in how we manage water.  But before we get to that, consider the challenges we face in our quest to conserve and renew water resources, while ensuring equal access to clean water for all peoples across the globe.

 

The Water Gap Challenges

We have several gaps between the need and desire to have abundant, accessible, clean water and the reality of dealing with on-going and increasing water shortage crises. These gaps occur in our awareness of the problem; in the cultural impact; the diverse quality of water; economic factors that deliver water; population density factors; regulatory impact; and the scale at which we address solutions. Each of these gaps deserves on-going, deep-dive conversations that this brief article cannot provide. But I will say that these conversations cannot be siloed into stand-alone challenges.  We must bring about holistic change through diverse forums of discovery that bridge multiple industries, policy-making authorities, and thought leaders.

 

Skagit County Justice Center Mount Vernon Washington DLR Group San Van FleetSkagit County Justice Center in Mount Vernon, Washington by DLR Group. Photo by Sam Van Fleet.

 

An example of this water gap reality hits home in the challenges that both Detroit and Flint, Michigan have faced. Both of these cities are situated at the edge of the most water-rich resource on the face of the planet – the Great Lakes comprise 21 percent of surface fresh water on the planet.  And yet, the huge number of citizens who had their water disconnected in Detroit due to an economic gap led to one of the highest rates of Hepatitis B virus in the country.  Similarly, in Flint, the quality gap in their water system made access to water a moot point.

 

Rethinking Water in Four Dimensions

Because we’ve come from a perspective of “sustainability” being measured by the amount of energy saved, we seem to have automatically slipped into the same metric for water.  Yes, it is a good thing to eliminate water waste, and to know and communicate how much water our designs are saving, but what if we looked at water from four dimensions of economics, risk, quality and the water-energy nexus.

1. Economics:  In this dimension we consider the cost of water delivered to our homes, the cost of sewer water (which is more expensive due to the energy and chemical treatment processes), and the cost of storm water, all based on the Clean Water Act. Water is still priced low but grows increasingly unaffordable in many parts of the world. What if we develop design solutions that minimize the cost of water reuse through closed-loop design solutions to capture water from one use and repurpose it for another use within a smaller context like a public restroom? Instead of sending water from hand washing faucets out of the building, we should route it to plumbing fixtures for added function.
 

2. Risk: The risk dimension is based on the frequency and intensity of water supply and demand, both now and into the future. The World Resources Institute uses a weighted risk factor calculation based on a global water risk mapping tool to help companies and governments understand where and how water risks and opportunities are emerging across the globe. Not only the pattern, but the frequency and intensity of water supply and demand will change in the future. What if we integrate this risk factor into design in terms of the lack of, or surplus of, water supply or demand? This thinking, for instance, could have an impact on the sizing of water capture and storage systems.
 

3. Quality:  Perhaps more than any other dimension, we have great opportunity to micro-define the quality of water based on a hierarchy of needs. These micro-definitions or degrees of water quality can differ based on the required need as shown in the graphic below. Identifying those degrees of quality can lead to water savings, both in quantity and dollars.

Hierarchy of Water Needs DLR GroupHierarchy of Water Needs by DLR Group.
 

4. Water-Energy Nexus: Calculating water beyond what a building uses to include the amount of water required to deliver the energy to that building is rising to the forefront of sustainability discussions. My colleague Tony Cocea penned an Insight on this topic and explained why integrating new calculations into the processes of building design can help us change the way we think about water, beyond what we personally use. Unveiling these hidden costs and hidden truths are vital in how we continue to use and conserve this life-giving resource.

 

Net Zero Water Approach DLR GroupNet Zero Water Approach DLR Group.

 

New Definitions and Metrics of Performance

1. The Building as Resource  
For decades we have considered buildings as a user and consumer of resources.  We have measured our success by how much we can limit that consumption. But if we flip that idea on its head and consider how we can reuse our water to nourish the environment, or how much and in what condition we return the water to the system, our buildings then become a resource provider rather than a consumer. 
 

2. Water Quality Ratio (WQR)
I propose a new framework to assessing water quality, to apply the appropriate quality of water for the appropriate water use. The WQR is the ratio of quality to any supply or demand for water, based on the quality of drinking water as established by World Health Organization. So, ideally, the tap water we receive at our homes would have a WQR of 1.0. This metric could become a standard rating applied to plumbing fixtures, equipment that uses water, air conditioning equipment, etc. in providing a level of water quality that is acceptable for its proper operation, as well as the resultant water quality. Such a water quality label, similar to ENERGY STAR and Water Sense could fundamentally change our perception of water quality and transform the market.
 

3. Engage in the Conversation
Find organizations that might focus on this topic and join their board, attend a workshop, or offer to be on a panel. Send a letter to your legislators related to the bills they are considering that address water resources. There are dozens of opportunities for people to bring a variety of perspectives to this conversation creating a more robust understanding of the issues.

The bottom line is that we can no longer ignore the water issues facing the world. And continuing to use metrics from the past to determine our water supply and our true water usage will only exacerbate the issues related to water economics, accessibility, and equity. Every step we take to change the way we think about water takes us closer to viable, holistic solutions.

DLR Group Insights Blog | DLR Group
DLR Group

DLR Group’s Insights Blog features commentary and thought leadership from the firm’s architecture, design, and engineering experts across more than a dozen core sectors: civic, courts, detention, energy services, healthcare, higher education, hospitality, K-12 education, museum, performing arts, retail, mixed-use, sports, workplace design, multifamily housing, and transportation. More at dlrgroup.com/insights

Related Blogs

April 23, 2018 | Multifamily Housing | DLR GroupJose Brunner

The adaptability of urban development could be revolutionized through the inherent strength of mass timber ...

April 11, 2018 | Education Facility | DLR GroupChristopher GIbbs

The task of providing safe and secure environments in which our children can learn is both complicated and...

April 04, 2018 | Energy Efficiency | DLR GroupRoger Chang

A building with a higher occupant density may have a higher energy use, but expend less energy per person....

March 12, 2018 | Office Building Design | DLR GroupAlison Zeno

Thoughtful design, paired with a change management program to educate staff, can both enhance connectivity...

March 05, 2018 | Healthcare Facilities | DLR GroupPhilip LiBassi

What exactly is the hospital of future? Or more specifically, what is the future of healthcare design?

February 28, 2018 | AEC Tech | DLR GroupRaymond Kent

Unlike other technologies we have seen, augmented and virtual reality are looking to have staying power in...

Pathfinder Kindergarten Center in Everett, Wash., by DLR Group
January 29, 2018 | Education Facility | DLR GroupTodd Ferking, AIA

The idea of a kindergarten-only school presents both challenges and opportunities in regards to the design....

Joplin (Mo.) Interim High School, designed by DLR Group. Photo courtesy DLR Group

Joplin (Mo.) Interim High School, designed by DLR Group. Photo courtesy DLR Group

January 22, 2018 | K-12 Schools | DLR GroupRaechel French, Associate, DLR Group

An education market think tank proposes a radical research concept for evaluating learning environments....

January 04, 2018 | Architects | DLR GroupSeth Trance

Homelessness is an issue affecting millions around the globe. 

November 17, 2017 | Architects | DLR GroupPaul Westlake

About 90% of the time prospective clients are not aware of historic tax credits.

Overlay Init