Most construction disputes are settled before they erupt into migraine-inducing litigation. But global asset volatility, currency turbulence, and the loss of economic momentum globally, have made dispute resolution tougher to reach amicably. And, in fact, for the third consecutive year, the length of disputes rose in 2015, according to a new report by Arcadis, the international design and consultancy firm, based on an in-depth review of projects that the firm’s Contract Solutions team handled last year.
Arcadis, which is active in 70 countries, defines a dispute as a “situation where two parties typically differ in the assertion of a contractual right.” Last year, the value of disputes fell by nearly 11% to an average of $46 million. However, the length of time it took to resolve these conflicts increased to a record average of 15.2 months, compared to 13.2 months in 2014 and 11.8 months in 2013.
The highest value dispute that Arcadis handled last year was worth a whopping $2.5 billion. (The firm did not state where that dispute arose.)
Contractual disputes took longer to mediate for the third consecutive year in 2015. The No. 1 cause for disputes continues to be faulty contract administration. Image: Arcadis “Global Construction Dispute Report 2016.”
“The increased length of disputes will have multiple effects for both parties and are likely to, ultimately, have a negative impact on the construction industry,” Arcadis cautions in its report.
The No. 1 cause for disputes was failure to properly administer a contract, followed by a poorly written draft and unsubstantiated claims. The property/real estate sector had the most disputes, followed by the social infrastructure/public sector. Arcadis notes, ruefully, that more than one-quarter of joint ventures end in disputes.
Party-to-party negotiation is still the most common form of resolving disputes. And the best ways to avoid disputes in the first place is to make sure the contract is administered properly, the documents are accurate, and the contract has fair and appropriate risk and balances.
While the number of disputes in North America was up last year, their average values and lengths dipped. The value of disputes last year averaged $25 million, a 15.5% drop from the previous year. And the length of disputes in North America was down by nearly three months, to an average of 13.5 months compared to 16.2 in 2014.
Arcadis notes that the U.S. was the only global region to achieve both a decrease in construction dispute values and length of time to resolve disputes last year. “But there is one downside,” notes Roy Cooper, a Vice President for Arcadis North America. “Even though more disputes are being settled early, the ones that remain grow into complicated, emotional affairs, with large damages at stake. These also take longer to resolve, since U.S. courts hate to try construction cases due to their large volumes of documents and greater complexity.”
In North America, errors and omissions in contracts documents are the most common reasons for disputes.
“We expect that the decline in duration and value will continue into 2016 as the industry [in North America] continues to recognize the importance of addressing disputes early in their lifecycle, and contracts are written with provisions giving strict instruction on how and when to address disputes,” writes Arcadis.
Conversely, the Middle East now surpasses Asia as Dispute Central when it comes to contractual disagreements. The average dispute value in that region jumped by 6.9% last year to $82 million, and the length of disputes rose marginally to an average of 15.2 months.
Disputes drag out even longer in Continental Europe, which averaged 18.5 months last year. “Conflicting party interests” was cited by Arcadis as the No. 1 cause for disputes.
Joint ventures are most vulnerable to contract disputes. And the Middle East far exceeds global averages in the value and lenght of its construction disputes. Image: Arcadis “Global Construction Dispute Report 2016.”
Related Stories
Contractors | Jun 13, 2023
The average U.S. contractor has 8.9 months worth of construction work in the pipeline, as of May 2023
Associated Builders and Contractors reported that its Construction Backlog Indicator remained unchanged at 8.9 months in May, according to an ABC member survey conducted May 20 to June 7. The reading is 0.1 months lower than in May 2022. Backlog in the infrastructure category ticked up again and has now returned to May 2022 levels. On a regional basis, backlog increased in every region but the Northeast.
Industry Research | Jun 13, 2023
Two new surveys track how the construction industry, in the U.S. and globally, is navigating market disruption and volatility
The surveys, conducted by XYZ Reality and KPMG International, found greater willingness to embrace technology, workplace diversity, and ESG precepts.
| Jun 5, 2023
Communication is the key to AEC firms’ mental health programs and training
The core of recent awareness efforts—and their greatest challenge—is getting workers to come forward and share stories.
Contractors | May 24, 2023
The average U.S. contractor has 8.9 months worth of construction work in the pipeline, as of April 2023
Contractor backlogs climbed slightly in April, from a seven-month low the previous month, according to Associated Builders and Contractors.
Multifamily Housing | May 23, 2023
One out of three office buildings in largest U.S. cities are suitable for residential conversion
Roughly one in three office buildings in the largest U.S. cities are well suited to be converted to multifamily residential properties, according to a study by global real estate firm Avison Young. Some 6,206 buildings across 10 U.S. cities present viable opportunities for conversion to residential use.
Industry Research | May 22, 2023
2023 High Growth Study shares tips for finding success in uncertain times
Lee Frederiksen, Managing Partner, Hinge, reveals key takeaways from the firm's recent High Growth study.
Multifamily Housing | May 8, 2023
The average multifamily rent was $1,709 in April 2023, up for the second straight month
Despite economic headwinds, the multifamily housing market continues to demonstrate resilience, according to a new Yardi Matrix report.
Market Data | May 2, 2023
Nonresidential construction spending up 0.7% in March 2023 versus previous month
National nonresidential construction spending increased by 0.7% in March, according to an Associated Builders and Contractors analysis of data published today by the U.S. Census Bureau. On a seasonally adjusted annualized basis, nonresidential spending totaled $997.1 billion for the month.
Hotel Facilities | May 2, 2023
U.S. hotel construction up 9% in the first quarter of 2023, led by Marriott and Hilton
In the latest United States Construction Pipeline Trend Report from Lodging Econometrics (LE), analysts report that construction pipeline projects in the U.S. continue to increase, standing at 5,545 projects/658,207 rooms at the close of Q1 2023. Up 9% by both projects and rooms year-over-year (YOY); project totals at Q1 ‘23 are just 338 projects, or 5.7%, behind the all-time high of 5,883 projects recorded in Q2 2008.
Market Data | May 1, 2023
AEC firm proposal activity rebounds in the first quarter of 2023: PSMJ report
Proposal activity for architecture, engineering and construction (A/E/C) firms increased significantly in the 1st Quarter of 2023, according to PSMJ’s Quarterly Market Forecast (QMF) survey. The predictive measure of the industry’s health rebounded to a net plus/minus index (NPMI) of 32.8 in the first three months of the year.