6 lessons from a true IPD project: George Washington University Hospital

In its latest blog post, Skanska shares tips and takeaways from the firm's second true integrated project delivery project.

August 26, 2014 |
Constructive Thinking Blog

Illustration: Skanska

More and more, teamwork, trust and collaboration are seen as key to successful project delivery. Yet, few projects seek to maximize the meanings behind those words by making them central to how the project team is structured and functions.

One approach that does so—integrated project delivery—binds major stakeholders through a mutual contract such that individual stakeholder success is tied to overall project success, with risk and reward both capped and shared.

While IPD is rare—in part because of the greater up-front effort required—the results are typically powerful, with better cost and schedule performances and a smoother delivery process.

To help others learn how IPD might help their projects, we recently checked in with the stakeholder team behind the second true IPD project with which Skanska is involved, an intensive care unit renovation at The George Washington University Hospital in Washington, D.C.

Here’s some of what this team recently had to share about this project, when on-site work was just getting underway.

1. All in: Seven organizations signed the IPD agreement: Universal Health Services (owner); Skanska (construction manager); WJ Architects (architect of record); In.Design (interior designer); Southland Industries (mechanical design-builder); M.C. Dean (electrical design-builder); and Clark’s Lumber and Millwork (millwork trade partner). With this arrangement, there are no separate contracts between the owner and the architect, construction managers and key trade contractors, and so on—every key firm is part of one contract to align all interests with that of the project.

2. Project finances in a new light: Owner Universal Health Services is accepting all risk for project cost and the overhead of the signatory partners, said Christian Pikel, UHS regional project manager. However, each partner’s profit is put at risk through a shared pool. Any savings from the target budget will be shared among participants, up to the profit pool cap.

3. Consensus-based objectives: Early in the project, team members and end users came together to define the project’s “conditions of satisfaction”—common team objectives. They crafted 10 of these statements, which include improving doctor, nurse and staff work flows within the sixth floor ICU; eliminating unanticipated noise from impacting adjacent spaces (the project is directly above an active intensive care unit); building a work environment in which all team participants demonstrate leadership roles and process improvement; and incorporate surge capacity within the project budget.

The team has developed a spreadsheet containing all conditions, and at every meeting they go down the list and rate their recent performance for each, said Andy Rhodes, Southland design engineer/project manager.

4. A3 library: IPD’s team-based nature makes it ideal for incorporating the principles and tools of lean construction, which focuses on eliminating waste and continual improvement. Of this project’s lean aspects, A3s are being used not just a single-page way to identify, analyze and propose solutions for problems, but as a means of sharing that thinking across projects.

“We were able to pull an A3 on a bariatric issue from another project,” said Aimee Fogarty, Skanska project manager. “By re-examining that document, we didn’t have to start from scratch.”

5. Better-informed design: This project’s designers are finding that IPD enables them to get the input they need to produce a more realistic design the first time.

“It helps clarify expectations much sooner, instead of the typical process of doing value engineering later on in traditional models,” said Jenna Santamaria, In.Design senior designer. “I really get excited and enjoy when we have some healthy tension going on in the Big Room: we get to start horse trading back and forth and asking ourselves, ‘What can we do to make this work?’”

6. Trust in the Big Room: IPD requires more up-front participation from all parties, including significant time spent in regular in-person Big Room meetings in which all team participants work together on project issues. Such meetings require a different mindset. For example, everyone has equal status and say in all matters. To keep everyone focused, multitasking and sidebar conversations aren’t allowed. And trust is of paramount importance.

“Each expert involved in the project must trust each other’s judgment because the success of the team determines the overall success of the project,” said Jennifer Macks, Skanska vice president. “Also, to make the most of the collaborative communication and problem-solving scenario, everyone must be comfortable with one another and share their expertise.”

 

Read more posts from Skanska's Constructive Thinking Blog

Constructive Thinking Blog | Constructive Thinking Blog
Skanska

Skanska USA is one of the largest, most financially sound construction and development networks in the country, serving a broad range of industries including healthcare, education, sports, data centers, government, aviation, transportation, power, energy, water/wastewater and commercial. Skanska USA is committed to a set of core values which they call the Five Zeros: zero loss making projects, zero environmental incidents, zero accidents, zero ethical breaches and zero defects. Constructive Thinking is Skanska USA’s blog, where team members share their experiences and viewpoints on Skanska’s core values and explore trends in U.S. construction, development and infrastructure.

Related Blogs

A rendering of Skanska's 88 M Street NE project in Washington, D.C., one of three reference buildings profiled in a recent study by the New Buildings Institute, International Living Future Institute, and Skanska. Photo: courtesy Skanska

September 29, 2014 | Constructive Thinking Blog

Skanska USA's Steve Clem breaks down the costs and benefits of various ultra-green building standards and p...

Illustration: Skanska

September 07, 2014 | Constructive Thinking Blog

In this new partnership, LEED will benefit from the materials expertise of ACC and its member companies. We...

MetLife Stadium, home to 2014s Super Bowl, is one of the greenest sports venues in the U.S. Photo: Skanska USA

August 20, 2014 | Constructive Thinking Blog
The WELL Building Standard, a new protocol that focuses on human wellness within the built environment, i...

For Good Samaritan Hospital, Skanska and the project team created a single enhanced interface for facilities management, streamlining the day-to-day building management process.

January 12, 2014 | Constructive Thinking Blog

Improved space management, streamlined maintenance, and economical retrofits are among the ways building ow...

December 09, 2013 | Constructive Thinking Blog

Life cycle cost optioneering is a way of assessing alternative design options, analyzing their long-term ca...

See the full infographic below. Source: Skanska USA

November 14, 2013 | Constructive Thinking Blog

In light of America's new energy resources and an increased emphasis on energy efficiency, Skanska examined...

 

Add new comment

Your Information
Your Comment

Filtered HTML

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
Refresh Type the characters you see in this picture. Type the characters you see in the picture; if you can't read them, submit the form and a new image will be generated. Not case sensitive.  Switch to audio verification.
Overlay Init