Do green building environments improve 'cognitive function'?

Researchers at Harvard, SUNY-Upstate Medical Center, and Syracuse University conduct a controlled experiment to see if high levels of carbon dioxide and VOCs and poor air ventilation affect cognitive scores.

December 02, 2015 |
Rob Cassidy

Ever since the green building movement kicked in nearly 20 years ago, a lot of claims have been made about the impact of high levels of carbon dioxide and volatile organic compounds, as well as the impact of low levels of fresh air circulation. For the most part, these claims were based on anecdotal information and hope, not hard science. Now, we may have at least one rigorous, peer-reviewed study that does show that improved indoor environmental quality can positively benefit human cognitive capability.

In the study, researchers from Harvard's T.H. Chan School of Public Health, SUNY-Upstate Medical Center (Syracuse), and Syracuse University subjected 24 participants to spend six full work days (9 a.m. – 5 p.m.) in an environmentally controlled office space, blinded to test conditions. On some days, the participants were exposed to IEQ conditions representative of "conventional" (high VOC concentration) and "green" (low VOC concentration) office buildings in the U.S. Other simulations tested the participants' cognitive skills in a green building with a high outdoor air ventilation rate ("Green+") and artificially elevated carbon dioxide levels independent of ventilation.

The research team found that, on average, participants' cognitive scores were 61% higher on the "green building day" and 101% higher on the two "Green+ building days" than on the so-called conventional building day (p<0.0001). VOCs and carbon dioxide were independently associated with cognitive scores.

The authors - Allen JG, MacNaughton P, Satish U, Santanam S, Vallarino J, Spengler JD - concluded that cognitive function scores were significantly better in Green+ building conditions compared to the conventional building conditions for all nine functional domains. The full report, "Associations of Cognitive Function Scores with Carbon Dioxide, Ventilation, and Volatile Organic Compound Exposures in Office Workers: A Controlled Exposure Study of Green and Conventional Office Environments," was published in the journal Environmental Health Perspectives.

This is the kind of research we've been looking for. We know instinctively and through experience that poor indoor air quality, whether through inadequate ventilation or the presence of VOCs or carbon dioxide, is somehow bad for us. We just didn't know how bad, nor what function or functions were most negatively affected.

Now we have a peer-reviewed, and therefore presumably replicable, scientific study that shows just how much these negative factors affect our ability to work and think while indoors, which is where most people spend as much as 90% of their lives. This gives architects, engineers, and contractors on the Building Team valuable data to advocate to their clients for the budget to make sure IEQ is a top priority in new and reconstructed building projects. The study is a refreshing antidote to the many unscientifically based claims put forth by green building advocates in the past.

Let's see more solid work like this in the future.

 

 

 

Rob Cassidy | BD+C Editors

Robert Cassidy is Executive Editor of Building Design+Construction and the Editor of Multifamily Design+Construction. A city planner, he is the author of several books, including “Livable Cities,” and was a co-founder of the Friends of the Chicago River.

Related Blogs

The Oxford word of the year: climate emergency. Graph sourced from the Oxford Corpus

November 20, 2019 | Sustainable Design and Construction | BD+C Editors

The Oxford Word of the Year 2019 is climate emergency.

ProForm Studio Bike Pro

Reviewer Elyse Betters-Picaro gives high marks to the ProForm Studio Bike Pro ($999) as her best buy for alternatives to Peloton. Photo: ProForm

November 08, 2019 | Multifamily Housing | BD+C Editors

ProForm Studio Bike Pro review.

Oslo opera house and public space

Courtesy Pixabay

November 01, 2019 | Transportation & Parking Facilities | BD+C Editors

Two recent reports (October 2019) explore whether car-free downtowns really work, based on experience in Os...

Peloton bikes at Weinstein Properties, Bexley Triangle Park, Raleigh, NC

Peloton bikes at Weinstein Properties, Bexley Triangle Park, Raleigh, NC. Courtesy Weinstein Properties

   

September 04, 2019 | Multifamily Housing | BD+C Editors

Peloton will no longer sell its bikes to apartment communities.

Suffolk Smart Lab in New York City, 2019 Giants 300 Report, 3 ‘Giant’ AEC market trends for 2019-2020  Photo: J. Michael Worthington, Jr., courtesy Suffolk Construction

The rise of data and data tools, like the Suffolk Smart Lab in New York City (pictured), is leading to more research projects among AEC firms. Photo: J. Michael Worthington, Jr., courtesy Suffolk Construction

  

August 15, 2019 | Giants 300 | BD+C Editors

We’re starting to see a shift toward custom research, thanks in part to the influx of data, data tools, and...

Amenities war no more? Research report explores multifamily market

The skylit 75-foot, three-lane lap pool at Hub, a 54-story rental tower of 750 apartments (150 affordable) in Brooklyn, N.Y., designed by Dattner Architects. Photo: Evan Joseph, courtesy Dattner Architects

July 31, 2019 | Multifamily Housing | BD+C Editors

Multifamily developers show no signs of pulling back on specialty spaces and unique offerings in an effort...

Annual mortgage payment plus property tax per average square foot of housing in US cities.

Source: World Business Chicago

April 30, 2018 | Multifamily Housing | BD+C EditorsRobert Cassidy

It's inaccurate to focus on property taxes as a percentage of home value without acknowledging the actual c...

MIT’s Simmons Hall, designed by Steven Holl

MIT’s Simmons Hall, designed by Steven Holl

January 05, 2018 | Big Data | BD+C EditorsDavid Barista, Editorial Director

At a time when research- and data-based methods are playing a larger role in architecture, there remains a...

Illustration: Pixabay

December 30, 2016 | Building Team | BD+C Editors

Women AEC professionals need you to take action. 

Lissette Méndez-Boyer (left) and Natalya Shimanovskaya work on their FABRICation project at Beyer Blinder Belle’s New York office. Photo courtesy BBB

September 06, 2016 | AEC Tech | BD+C Editors

AEC firms are taking a page from the tech industry, by infusing a deep commitment to innovation and disrupt...

Overlay Init