Microsoft shutters classic clipart gallery: Reaction from a graphic designer

Microsoft shut down its tried-and-true clipart gallery, ridding the world not only of a trope of graphic design, but a nostalgic piece of digital design history, writes HDR's Dylan Coonrad.

January 08, 2015 |
HDR Insights

Courtesy Dylan Coonrad, HDR

Hear ye, hear ye! [cue trumpets]

Earlier this week, Microsoft shut down the classic clipart gallery. [cue gasps]

You’d probably think I’d be applauding the move as a designer. After all, clipart joins the ranks of Comic Sans and drop shadows as one of the most maligned graphic tropes of the digital age. I thought I’d be clapping too, but instead my jaw dropped. Granted, it doesn’t take much for my jaw to drop [see Doritos Locos Tacos commercial] but this announcement hit me pretty close to home. Here’s why.

I never really understood the word “design” growing up. My mom told me at a young age that she thought I’d make a good designer or engineer one day, and I remember being a little insulted. The word “designer” sounded like a made-up word (there’s no way I could spell it with that silent g in the mix) and I thought “engineer” meant train conductor. Great aspirations, mom. It wasn’t until a few years later that the word clicked. [insert lightbulb]

Computers were just starting to become mainstream in my middle school years, but you can be sure I already knew my way around Microsoft Word like a wunderkind. My first foray into the practice of clipart was a history report on ancient cultures. My teacher proudly shared with classes and colleagues the context-appropriate Egyptian-themed clip art I cleverly nestled within the narrative. Bravos came from all around.

Clipart is what made my work the talk of the sixth grade. I learned years later that my Spanish teacher fabricated an assignment for the sole reason to see a "Dylan Coonrad original Powerpoint." At age 11, I assembled the first-ever youth soccer newsletter that landed on over 4,000 doorsteps in town. I’ll never forget it. The title of the tri-fold brochure was set in Yearbook Outline—a font exclusive to MS Publisher 95—above a full-bleed birds-eye soccer field background. Scattered through the interior articles was a carefully curated selection of soccer-related clipart, colors, and graphics that complimented each other in ways only a sixth grader could rationalize. Primary typeface: Comic Sans (naturally). Drop shadows: everywhere. The town was abuzz. I got numerous requests for repeat work, and one fan called to praise my design, adding that it encouraged her to enroll her kids in the program that very week.

It took a while, but I began to notice a trend: I had a talent of creating memorable work. That’s when it hit me: I was indeed capable of this “design” thing. (Just goes to show, moms are always right.) Design isn’t just little cartoons or trendy fonts. Design has the power to inspire and connect. Design is thinking made visual. Clip art taught me to use design as a tool to enhance experiences. How else can I add value to this project that goes beyond the requirements? How can I demonstrate concepts in ways that connect with the audience?

From then on, clipart was the belle of the ball for me. There wasn’t a single document that got printed without some kind of clipart flourish. 

Fast forward to today: I don’t even own a printer. I can’t remember the last time the paper clip popped up to help me write a letter, but I’m sad to see it all go. However, there might be a hidden motivator behind Microsoft’s decision. Sure, the clipart gallery doesn’t align with their refreshed clean-cut aesthetic, but maybe Microsoft is trying to challenge us. What do custom birthday cards look like without the typical birthday cake and candle cartoon? What could be on the cover of a book report without a stack of books or Shakespearean quill? We live in a brave new world, indeed.

I still subconsciously accompany words with other sensory images when I write--hence the [annotations] in this post. Don't get me wrong: I haven't used clip art in 15+ years, but I’m finding myself reaching towards Insert > Picture > Clipart, if only to pay homage to an age-old habit.

So here’s to you, clipart. You taught me to leverage associations and experiences as a form of communication. You taught me how to proportionally scale artwork. While the modern-day professional in me considers this a cause to celebrate, the curious young designer feels like he lost a dear friend. [cue sniffles]

Here’s one thing I won’t miss, Microsoft: Word Art. [cue war cries]

About the author

Dylan Coonrad is a graphic designer on a mission: to be the greatest of all time, and also to pay as little for lunch as possible. He is constantly researching new ideas and creating unexpected connections with his graphic work. He’s also a monster on the volleyball court! Don’t let his super-manliness fool you—he has a sensitive side too. In addition to graphic designing (for business and pleasure), Coonrad is working on his debut country album, “Slowing it Down, Twanging it Up: Pop Country Remixes.”

HDR Insights | HDR
HDR

Our blogs are written by our employees at HDR. While we are most well-known for delivering architecture and engineering services—for adding beauty and structure to communities through high performance buildings and smart infrastructure, we provide much more than that. We create an unshakable foundation for progress because our multidisciplinary teams also include scientists, economists, builders, analysts and artists. Our thought leader bloggers represent offices from around the world and write about ideas, experiences and insights into our practice and the greater design community. Come visit us at Insights @hdrinc.com.

Related Blogs

April 04, 2017 | Building Team | HDRJeri Brittin, Director of Research, HDR

Many assume that post-occupancy (POE) is a clearly-defined term and concept, but the meaning of POE in prac...

March 24, 2017 | Healthcare Facilities | HDRJoel Worthington & Beth Zacherle

Pediatric experience design must evolve beyond the common mantra of “make it fun” or “make it look kid-frie...

January 19, 2017 | Sustainability | HDRJennifer Bienemann, Environmental Engineer, HDR

To help one of the most complex cities in the world develop an actionable strategy to meet visionary GHG re...

October 21, 2016 | Architects | HDRLynn Mignola, Strategic Facilities Planner

Sometimes people look only for the simple answer and don’t understand that there is a calculated process to...

Pixabay Public Domain

October 03, 2016 | HDRJoel Worthington, Strategic Innovation Designer

Know what you're working toward, be empathetic, and listen actively are three tips HDR's Joel Worthington s...

September 08, 2016 | Sustainability | HDRLynn Mignola

When it comes to design we are in the business of imagining what could be, not necessarily what is, writes...

Courtesy of HDR

August 10, 2016 | Healthcare Facilities | HDRBrian Zabloudil, Healthcare Planner

Engagement at all levels, designing with families in mind, and integrating flexible spaces are all importan...

Images courtesy HDR

June 14, 2016 | Office Building Design | HDRLynn Mignola

Recent design trends favor extroverts who enjoy collaboration. HDR's Lynn Mignola says that designers need...

How HDR used computational design tools to design Omaha's UNO Baxter Arena

The new Baxter Arena in Omaha, Neb. Photo: Dan Schwalm, courtesy of HDR Architecture, Inc. Click here to enlarge.

May 02, 2016 | BIM and Information Technology | HDRMatt Goldsberry

Three years after writing a white paper about designing an arena for the University of Nebraska Omaha, HDR'...

Identifying, using, and applying predictive analytics

Photo: Jeff Seeger/Creative Commons

March 28, 2016 | Big Data | HDRBranden Collingsworth

Branden Collingsworth, HDR’s new Director of Predictive Analytics, clarifies what his team does and how arc...

Overlay Init