Let’s be civil in debate over green building standards

August 07, 2012 |
Rob Cassidy

There’s a nasty brouhaha going on in Washington over green building standards. On one side is the U.S. Green Building Council, promulgator of the LEED rating program; on the other, a new coalition of building product makers who say LEED does not meet ANSI-type “consensus” standards.

The new group, the American High-Performance Buildings Coalition, represents 27 membership associations, including the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, the National Association of Manufacturers, and the American Chemistry Council. These entities cover many of the products that go into buildings: roofing, sealants, vinyl, lumber, windows, etc.

The AHPBC’s mission (see www.betterbuildingstandards.com) is to support green building rating systems that are “developed in conformance with ANSI or ISO-type consensus processes, are data-driven, supported by science, and performance-based.”

In a recent telecon with the media, AHPBC members complained that the process for updating LEED (which is now going through its fourth revision) lacks transparency, is not based on science, and has not been responsive to questions and comments from industry.

Craig Silvertooth, of the Center for Environmental Innovation in Roofing, said that the USGBC recently allowed only a couple of weeks for interested parties to submit comments on proposed standards that would have “deselected” 90% of commonly used roofing membranes and 90% of roofing insulation materials from LEED-rated buildings.

In contrast, noted Jared Blum, of the Polyisocyanurate Manufacturers Association, the International Code Council held extensive hearings and responded to all comments before adopting the new IgCC green code. Others mentioned ASHRAE, the National Fire Protection Association, and ASTM International as examples of standard-setting organizations that follow an ANSI-type consensus process.

For its part, the USGBC sent out emails asking member organizations to sign a letter to the GSA against “false and misleading claims from narrow interest groups seeking to undermine [USGBC’s] credibility.” 

Shortly afterwards, USGBC CEO Rick Fedrizzi wrote a strongly worded commentary for the Huffington Post entitled “The Scoundrel’s Handbook,” in which he accused unnamed “scoundrels” and “enemies” of the USGBC of attempting “to savage a mountain of scientific evidence in favor of obfuscation and innuendo.”

All this comes in the context of the revision to LEED, which has now been postponed till 2013, and a review by the GSA as to which rating system it will use (currently, the GSA seeks LEED Gold for most of its projects). Both sides are doing their best to influence the media, the GSA, and Congress, and the discussion has become acrimonious.

We think it’s time for a cooling-down period. The two sides need to meet in a civilized format—not through emails and press releases—to get the issues on the table and see where agreement is at least within talking range.

We propose that the USGBC and the AHPBC hire a certified conciliation facilitator to mediate such a meeting, with no more than four participants each. The facilitator would be charged with keeping the discussion focused on areas of agreement and possible further discussion.

Let’s defuse this situation and get the vitriol out of the green building rating discussion. +

Rob Cassidy | Building Team Blog

Rob Cassidy (“ClimateGrouch”) is editorial director of Building Design+Construction. A city planner, he is the author of several books, including “Livable Cities,” and was a co-founder of the Friends of the Chicago River.

Related Blogs

How the Fourth Industrial Revolution will alter the globe’s workforce

Photo: Pixabay

January 26, 2016 | BIM and Information Technology | Building Team Blog

The next great technological metamorphosis will be unlike anything humankind has experienced before, due to...

Potential vs. credential: How men and women differ in career progress

Courtesy Pixabay

January 05, 2016 | Architects | Building Team BlogDavid Barista, Editorial Director

Recent research suggests that women face yet another career impediment: the confidence gap.

Meet the world’s next great construction superpower

Photo: Wili Hybrid via Wikimedia Commons 

December 23, 2015 | Industry Research | Building Team Blog

There’s a new world construction hotbed coming down the pike (more specifically, the Mumbai Nashik Expressw...

Photo: Deskmag via Wikimedia Commons

December 02, 2015 | Building Team Blog

Researchers at Harvard, SUNY-Upstate Medical Center, and Syracuse University conduct a controlled experimen...

Leadership or limbo: Moving to building green’s next level

3 PNC Plaza. Photo: John Marino via flickr Creative Commons

November 29, 2015 | Green | Building Team Blog

After interviewing more than 50 AEC firms for our Greenbuild Report in the November issue, I wonder if the...

Benjamin Kasdan, AIA, LEED AP, NCARB, Design Director/Senior Designer with KTGY Architecture + Planning, Irvine, Calif. (Class of 2015 40 Under 40 winner)

October 26, 2015 | Building Team Blog

Are you an AEC superstar? The 2016 "40 Under 40" competition is now open for entries. Here are some helpful...

Competency-based learning: A glimpse into the future of higher education?

Photo: Xbxg32000 via Wikimedia Commons

October 16, 2015 | University Buildings | Building Team Blog

For better or worse, the higher education experience for many young Millennials and Gen Zers will not resem...

From Gehry to the High Line: What makes a project a game-changer?

El Peix sculpture in Barcelona, by Frank Gehry. Photo: Till Niermann via Wikimedia Commons

September 24, 2015 | Architects | Building Team Blog

Each year, there are a handful of projects that significantly advance the AEC industry or a particular buil...

Why AEC firms should be cultivating 'visible experts'

Photo: Cydcor via flickr creative commons

July 07, 2015 | Architects | Building Team Blog

A new study pinpoints the true dollar value of having knowledge leaders and market shapers on your team....

Add new comment

Your Information
Your Comment

Filtered HTML

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <cite> <blockquote> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
Refresh Type the characters you see in this picture. Type the characters you see in the picture; if you can't read them, submit the form and a new image will be generated. Not case sensitive.  Switch to audio verification.
Overlay Init