BIM vs VDC…how the US and the UK differ in approaching digital project delivery

In this four-part series, Bluebeam VP Sasha Reed sat down with industry experts to examine the need for defining and understanding digital workflows and data management throughout the design and construction project lifecycle.

Sponsored content
September 19, 2017 |
Sasha Reed
4 people speaking on a panel

Over the past four years, I’ve traveled between the US, and the UK to learn how BIM is impacting projects of all sizes and scale.  Along the way I asked myself, were there lessons to be learned in one market that the other hadn’t yet uncovered?  Were there pitfalls experienced in one country that could translate into meaningful insights for the other?  Would they even be willing to learn from each other’s experiences?  And what I’ve noticed is that beyond the obvious differences we all are aware of, like the UK’s government mandate requiring BIM Level 2 for all public sector projects and the lack of top-down pressure in the US, we’re not that much different.  Sure, our approaches may be nuanced based on our laws, project hierarchy and contracts but fundamentally we’re all focused on solving the same equation…how can we collaborate more effectively on projects, leveraging digital information between as many project stages as possible.

Or so I thought until I stumbled across this lively twitter exchange sparked by the well-respected, Casey Rutland, on the topic of BIM vs VDC vs digital engineering.  Seeing the passionate and multi-perspective responses in the thread, I knew it was time to dig beneath the surface and see what we agree and disagree on when it comes to BIM, not only for design but also for construction and beyond.

To have this discussion, I assembled a panel of BIM experts from the US and the UK to talk through the finer points of BIM, VDC, and data-enabled project delivery.  The panelists were Nigel Davies – Director of Evolve Consultancy, Brok Howard – Technical Account Manager with dRofus and Josh Bone – President of J. Bone Technology.  We met up at the Bluebeam eXtreme Conference, where I invited them to participate in a panel entitled, “BIM in Practice: Maximizing Data through Digital Workflows”. After presenting to the audience I pulled them off stage to sit down and talk at a deeper level about a few key points.   

 

BIM vs VDC…is there a difference?

To kick things off, I picked up the conversation sparked on Twitter and asked our experts to weigh in.  How do our two countries differ on the means and methods for delivering digital information?

 

BIM: Data you need when you need it

If BIM is considered the mechanism for how we work together then data is the what that’s delivered throughout the BIM process.  But how do we differ in what information we specify as valuable, and to whom and when?

 

Can BIM Improve Project Collaboration?

Much of what hinders accountability and trust within traditional project delivery methods is a lack of transparency.  If BIM is how we work together and data is what we share, then who we share information with and when is the key to improving collaboration.  Are we truly collaborating better with BIM?

 

BIM vs PDF: Why argue file types?

Some BIM experts narrow the scope of what can be defined as BIM and end up arguing about file types.  The trouble is, many General Contractors who work with downstream project partners that struggle to evolve beyond paper-based workflows, having 2D and 3D information that’s easily accessible, is key to being able to participate on BIM projects. 

In a recent McGraw Hill Smart Market Report on “The Business Value of BIM for Construction in Major Global Markets” the top benefits General Contractors cited as the benefits of BIM were; reduced errors and omissions, collaboration with owners/design firms, and reduced error and rework.  If BIM is how we work together and data is what we share, and who we share information with and when is the key to improving collaboration, then PDF absolutely has a role to play.  But will our experts agree?

 

In the end, it was clear that the experts agreed more than they disagreed.  Each looked at the implementation of BIM on a project from a different vantage point but one thing was clear.  The benchmark was the same – “how effectively are they able to communicate?”  Without improving baseline outcomes like that, we must step back and ask ourselves, “What real problem are we trying to solve?

Sasha Reed | StrXur by Bluebeam
Bluebeam, Inc.
Vice President of Strategic Development

As Vice President of Strategic Development at Bluebeam, Inc., Sasha Reed collaborates with leaders in the architecture, engineering and construction industry to guide Bluebeam’s technology, partnerships and long-term goals. She joined Bluebeam in 2007 and co-created the Concierge Approach, a distinctly branded process of customer engagement, product feedback and solution delivery to which much of Bluebeam’s success is attributed, and which today is replicated at every organizational level.

Sasha is known industry-wide as a “conversation facilitator,” creating platforms for exchanges necessary to digitally advance the industry, including the BD+C Magazine Digital COM Blog, which she authors and manages. She’s been a featured presenter at numerous national and international conferences, including the 2014 Design-Build Institute of America (DBIA), Federal Project Delivery Symposium and NTI Danish BIM Conference. Sasha also co-chairs the Construction PDF Coalition, a grassroots effort to provide a common industry framework from which to create and maintain construction PDF documents, serves on the City College of San Francisco BIM Industry Council, and is Advisor to the Board of Direction for the National Institute of Building Sciences BuildingSMART Alliance.

Related Blogs

A hospital under construction
August 28, 2017 | Healthcare Facilities | StrXur by Bluebeam

McCarthy will continue to lean on Bluebeam solutions to help solve the most critical issues, and to keep th...

An exterior shot of the Beijing National Stadium
August 17, 2017 | Building Materials | StrXur by Bluebeam

Lighter than glass and 100% recyclable, one material takes center stage in the future of building.

Rendering of a Matrix-style theater
August 02, 2017 | Architects | StrXur by Bluebeam

An Australian Home Theater Company is out to prove that the easier you can see it, the easier you can sell...

July 19, 2017 | Architects | StrXur by Bluebeam

Our goal is to present unique perspectives you may not be able to find anywhere else.  

July 13, 2017 | Accelerate Live! | StrXur by Bluebeam

From my perspective, what separates organizations thriving in the digital revolution from those who are not...

March 15, 2017 | StrXur by Bluebeam

Who is succeeding, and on what terms? And what will it take for everyone to experience the benefits of that...

October 04, 2016 | Building Team | StrXur by Bluebeam

As the construction industry bounces back from the Great Recession, an entirely new class of tech-savvy con...

July 11, 2016 | Building Team | StrXur by Bluebeam

The lead up to AECX featured a discussion providing insight into the current state of the AEC technological...

June 23, 2016 | StrXur by Bluebeam

Two truths from the jobsite: 1) The best part about uncovering a problem is discovering its solution, and 2...

June 09, 2016 | AEC Tech | StrXur by Bluebeam

Rather than fighting to control the proliferation of apps, perhaps we should be training our eyes to look f...

Overlay Init